I must say that being at the lower level would probably help in a nationally televised debate. Much of America is, well let's face it, stupid. The more the Senator or Governor talk down to the general public the better? I know it seems to be quite an irrational argument and implies a lot, or does it?
Kurtin...are you a guy? I dunno but I keep picturing you as a gal. But anyway my husband said the same thing as you pretty much. Most of the public does better at a 6th grade level. If that's the case, Biden did better than Palin looking at it that way.
Point being, judging someone based on their speech patterns or pronunciation skills can often be not only incorrect in terms of their actual intellect or ability but is generally seen as 'elitist'.
This reminds me of my own speech patterns. I am constantly getting down here in FL either "what part of Boston are you from" or "what part of New England are you from?"
Today in Walgreens a guy was having trouble on the machine that you select pictures with your camera photo card as I was sitting at the other machine. I offered to help him and as I told him what he needed to do he asked me what part of Boston I was from. He's a "New Youka" (get it?) We take r's out of where they should be and add them when they shouldn't be. Like we say "cah" instead of "car." I sak "Mauk" instead of "Mark."
So tonight we had company from a trio who came for visitation from a local church. We went to their church only once so they had never met us. We all hit it off great and then the older gentleman asked about our kids. When I gave him the info, he remarked at how smart they all were. When he asked who they took after I deferred to my husband as the brains in the family and he said he didn't know but that I was pretty smart myself. So I guess it's true, language or speech patterns should not dictate IQ.
Although we've all heard the saying it's better to keep your mouth shut and let others think you're stupid than to open your mouth and remove all doubt. But then again, it not how you're saying things, but what you're saying that tells the story. 