lordkosc lordkosc

Sins Game Review Thread

▼

Sins Game Review Thread

One thread to hold them all!

from Sins Forums

Ok , after the 20 or so preview threads that were all over the darn place, I am making a single location where we can post all the reviews of the game for easy reference.

So once you find a review, post it in the following format:

I hope this will be made sticky by someone from SD. :CONGRAT:

*******************************************************************************************

PC GAMER

91%

Editor's Choice

*******************************************************************************************

GameSpot

WWW Link

9/10

Editor's Choice

*******************************************************************************************

Games for Windows

A-

Editor's Choice

*******************************************************************************************

G4 X-Play

WWW Link

4/5

*******************************************************************************************

IGN

WWW Link

8.9/10

Editors' Choice



*******************************************************************************************

1up.com

WWW Link

8.5/10 Good

*******************************************************************************************


Gamespy

WWW Link

4.5/5 GREAT!

Multiplayer Factor - Great!

*******************************************************************************************

Game Informer Magazine

WWW Link

9/10

*******************************************************************************************

Gamer 2.0

WWW Link

9/10

*******************************************************************************************

Game Shark

WWW Link

A- Great

*******************************************************************************************

Game Squad

WWW Link

9/10 GREAT!


*******************************************************************************************

Resonance Gaming

WWW Link

9/10 GREAT!

*******************************************************************************************

Game Tap

WWW Link

9/10 Get It!


*******************************************************************************************
Out of Eight

WWW Link

8/8 GREAT!

*******************************************************************************************
Game Daily

WWW Link

8.0 GOOD

*******************************************************************************************

Shack News

WWW Link

Good:
# Patience-demanding strategy
# Endless possibility of scenarios
# Pew-pew lasers

Bad:
# No single-player campaign
# Steep learning curve

*******************************************************************************************

UGO

WWW Link

A

*******************************************************************************************

Game Almighty

WWW Link

9.0

*******************************************************************************************

GamesRadar

WWW Link

9/10

*******************************************************************************************

Gaming Steve

WWW Link

9/10

*******************************************************************************************

ArchGamer

WWW Link

8.5/10 Good

*******************************************************************************************

Sarcastic Gamer

WWW Link

9/10 Great

*******************************************************************************************

Dual Analog

WWW Link

9/10 Great

*******************************************************************************************

PALGN

WWW Link

9/10

*******************************************************************************************

Game Valor

WWW Link

9/10

*******************************************************************************************

SyndicateX Gaming Portal

WWW Link

9.3/10

*******************************************************************************************

Cheat Code Central

WWW Link

4.8/5.0

*******************************************************************************************

ArsGeek

WWW Link

9.25/10

*******************************************************************************************

EuroGamer

WWW Link

9/10

*******************************************************************************************

Sci Fi

WWW Link

A+

*******************************************************************************************

Firing Squad

WWW Link

91%

Editor's Choice

*******************************************************************************************

Gaming Nexus

WWW Link

9.2/10

*******************************************************************************************

Computer Games

WWW Link

85/100

Silver Award

*******************************************************************************************

Gamepyre

WWW Link

95%

Gamers Choice Gold Award

*******************************************************************************************

TGR

WWW Link

8/10

Editor's Choice Award


*******************************************************************************************

StratergyCore

WWW Link

8/10


///// UPDATED LIST as of 7/14/08

392,694 views 250 replies
Reply #126 from Sins Forums Top
the one point every reviewer made was a lack of single player campaign.

i was wondering, if there are tools already made or in the works to make your own campaign with objectives and scripts?
Reply #127 from Sins Forums Top
1UP review score just changed from 8.5 to 8.0!

Is there a conspiracy going on against this game??
Offworld Trading Company
Reply #128 from Sins Forums Top

1UP review score just changed from 8.5 to 8.0!

Is there a conspiracy going on against this game??


Ah, it's still 8.5.
Reply #129 from Sins Forums Top
Huh?? the avg score was 7.7 and review score was 8.0.
I even double checked. But now when I go and check again, it came back to 8.5...
Really weird...I swear that all the score went down. I even checked the review and it had the same exact review article..
Reply #130 from Sins Forums Top
Did you also notice the same program xplay had SINS as #3 top selling strategy game? Ahead of Starcraft battle chest, which has been out what, 8 years? And, C&C 3.

pek
Reply #133 from Sins Forums Top
9 days. 9 days and we only have 6 professional reviews. Can't you devs make death threats or something. Hire some enforcers?
Reply #134 from Sins Forums Top
We actually don't mind too much. We want reviewers to spend a lot of time with Sins and not play the game for 30 minutes only to trash it. ;)
Reply #135 from Sins Forums Top
Thanks for the compliment crusader. I felt like the quality really shone through on this game. I play a lot of games and review the ones I get around to (I have a full-time job and run that site as a hobby). Sins really stood out as a very solid package for any sort of strategy fans. Also, Ironclad seems to really care and be in touch with their fans.

I was impressed and will continue playing!
Reply #136 from Sins Forums Top
I see the Gamespot review up; 9.0 and an Editor's Choice.

http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/sinsofasolarempire/index.html?tag=topten;all;title;4
Reply #137 from Sins Forums Top
G4's X-Play gives Sins a 4 out of 5 stars.


Link
Reply #138 from Sins Forums Top
i was wondering what the devs (and any other people) thought about the main gripe reviewers had with the game: lack of a campaign. most of the reviews i read or watched noted that as the reason for dropping it from 9.5 to 9.0 or 9.0 to 8.5 (i won' even bother mentioning those that gave it a straight 8.0: they are idiots).
i love sins, but i would be interested in being able to download a campaign, or make your own. is this a future possibility, or will we not see this until an xpack or sequel?
Reply #139 from Sins Forums Top
Ironclad has stated we won't see a campaign until the expansion pack comes out.
Reply #140 from Sins Forums Top
that's a shame. that will chase some people away from this amazing game.
i think that if there was a single player cammaign, g4 and gamespy would have given it 5/5, and sites like ign and gamespot who haven't covered the final compy yet would really plug this game.

edit: gamespot just posted their review.
9/10 and editor's choice (WOOHOO!!)
Reply #141 from Sins Forums Top
A 9.0 from Gamespot!? Wow. You guys should be really proud.
Reply #142 from Sins Forums Top
First, I want to congratulate all the team, for that awesome game, and these praises you're receiving are well earned. :CONGRAT:
Reply #143 from Sins Forums Top
 :D Thanks guys!  We have a few more to go - our fingers are crossed :P
Reply #144 from Sins Forums Top
I just found this, and since I did not see it on this thread, I am posting the reference. The OP could integrate it in his own format :

Reviewer : James Allen
Website : Out of Eight PC Game Reviews
DATE : 11 February 2008
SCORE : 8 / 8


Link : Out of Eight
Reply #145 from Sins Forums Top
Just wanted to express my thanks for making such an amazingly polished product. The gameplay brings alot of fresh idea's to an already conviluded gerne without being overly confusing. Everything in this game feels right and intuitive. Big tumbs up to the development team and publisher!
Reply #146 from Sins Forums Top
I want to congratulate all the team, for that awesome game, and these praises you're receiving are well earned.

My sentiments exactly.
Reply #148 from Sins Forums Top
confusing retail outlets and their ineptitude when it comes to giving out release dates is why digital downloads are sweet.
Reply #149 from Sins Forums Top
"(try giving a TEC colonization frigate a few orders to attack – just try it!)."

They can attack!? Really!? *goes to try*
Reply #150 from Sins Forums Top
"i was wondering what the devs (and any other people) thought about the main gripe reviewers had with the game: lack of a campaign. most of the reviews i read or watched noted that as the reason for dropping it from 9.5 to 9.0 or 9.0 to 8.5 (i won' even bother mentioning those that gave it a straight 8.0: they are idiots).
i love sins, but i would be interested in being able to download a campaign, or make your own. is this a future possibility, or will we not see this until an xpack or sequel?"

I didn't doc the game because of this in my review (see my earlier post) because of this reasoning: for most RTS games I've played, the campaign serves as a tutorial to get you used to the gameplay, units and tech. You don't get to play with all the fun units, buildings and more until the last mission(s) of the game. The storyline has the potential to add a lot to the gameplay but it also can detract from it by interrupting the mission with cutscenes and plot that may not interest the gamer at all.

Sins sets the stage with the intro and a few tutorials. Then, every skirmish is like a campaign that you can tailor. You can build alliances and implement economic, diplomatic or military strategies along the way and explore and expand to your hearts content.

I was somewhat surprised that Sins didn't have a campaign but forgot about it roughly 7.36874 minutes into my first skirmish (roughly). A campaign would be a good thing if it's properly implemented into the game experience but the game is solid without it.