singrdave singrdave

Lose the Maiden Names!

Lose the Maiden Names!

When we marry I'd like five last names, if you please.

I have a rant, and I think you'll either agree with me wholeheartedly or completely flame me over this.

I cannot stand it when a woman insists on hyphenating her married name with her maiden name. To see people saddled with two or three surnames is just mean-spirited. I understand that women want to express their independence and their non-subjugation to their husband, but stop thinking about yourself for a moment...

THINK OF THE CHILDREN!

I know several children who have their parents' names, both with a big ol' hyphen in the middle. One in particular, he was one of my Cub Scouts last year. His name is Xavier C-W (not gonna put his whole name out on the web, especially since he is a minor...) and this poor little boy has two names. But, when I met his dad, he had the same name! Hugh C-W! Turns out HIS mother had insisted on keeping her surname. And their child, the dad of my Cub Scout, was saddled with the C-W surname. And his wife, when they married, had to take on the C-W surname. (Or, even more laughably, her own surname hyphenated along with her husband's already hyphenated surname!) And the grandson suffers, as will the grandson (my Scout) when he gets married and has children of his own. Turns out Mrs. C, generations back, will burden her progeny for generations to come.

I have another friend, this time a grown one, who recently got married. His name was Christopher G-M. Three long names in their own right, surnames dumped upon him at birth. His new wife had to take them, as well. As will their children.

I have it on good authority that until recently, in Quebec, the children had been forced to mandatorily take on both parents' surnames at birth. So as not to cause consternation, I guess. But then, a couple generations later, the problem was that people who already had two last names were marrying people who already had two last names... as you can see, this was getting out of hand. Four surnames, then eight, then sixteen. Reminds me of a bacterial infection or a mathematics problem.

MANDATORY DISCLAIMER:
I realize that I am a man. And my wife took my last name.

But she did so creatively! Her maiden name was C. Her middle name is now C, and her last name (like mine) is R. She is Bonnie C. R.... And when she got her college diploma, though she had earned it before she got married, she had it typed up with her married name.

All I ask is that when you're about to get married, please consider the long-term consequences of your actions. You may want your identity now, but will your great-grandchildren want it, too?
16,923 views 30 replies
Reply #26 Top
A couple of successive generations of people with hyphenated-last names marrying each other could eventually lead to some really long last names. That will be fun. Kind of like the Monty Python where there was a guy being announced in court with an extremely long last name. (Actually they used variants of that joke a few times.)


Hmong people are forbidden from having two people with the same last name marry each other. (There aren't many last names to choose from) After marriage, moms and dads still have different last names. (I think that kids get dad's name.
Reply #27 Top
I have several friends of my own generation, (20s-30s) who have all kept their original last names when they've gotten married. They also intend to have two children, per couple...so that each kid can have one of the names.

Isn't it about time we stop focusing so much on "tradition" and "expected roles" and just be accepting of whatever works for individual people, couples and families?
Reply #28 Top
They also intend to have two children, per couple...so that each kid can have one of the names.

I can see the introductions now... "Hi, my name is Anne Smith and here's my brother, John Douglas..."?
That's just adding more confusion to an already chaotic situation. Are we to assume that Anne and John are half-siblings? No, they are fully sibs, with different last names.
That is just short-sighted and ridiculous.
Reply #29 Top
That is just short-sighted and ridiculous.


I guess I just don't see how other people choose to name their kids effects anyone else...I mean, quite frankly, there are loads of names out there that parents give that I think are silly and stupid, but they are entitled to name their kid "Peanutbutter Jelly Sandwich" if that's what their heart desires.

If I ever get married, and I choose to keep my name, its a personal decision. It's about what I am comfortable with--not whether or not someone down the street gets bent out of shape by having to remember my name. And quiet frankly, it's incredibly rude to not recognize someone's name choice and insist on calling them something else. If your name is Bob and I call you Mike every day, chances are you are going to get a bit annoyed--I'm sure the same happens for people who get called the last name repeatedly. It's all about having manners.
Reply #30 Top
Are we to assume


I think the point here is that you shouldn't make assumptions. People choose to do what they do and they have their own reasons for it. You find it troubling because it's outside of what you consider to be the "norm", but others see the world differently.

I had a former boss who drilled the following concept into my head: Just because something has always been done a certain way does not mean that we should keep on doing it that way. To assume so would be poor logic.