Looks like some damn fine games in there to me. I don't see consoles any less plagued by genre titles, even more so, frankly. I still play PC titles from the late 90's, and the ones that can be modded are even more so. If anything the lack of innovation in such lists just shows that these game review sites don't bother to go out and find much.
I don't even have to pay for the mods, either. There are console games that stand that test of time, but the consoles themselves rarely do. My N64 died a few days ago, so I'll either buy a new one, or the games I have on the shelf are dead to me.
PCs offer emulation, modding, unfettered networks play not reliant on the devs ongoing monetary interest, etc. You can still go and play MUDs for heaven's sake. I don't think PC games are dead, they are even more valid as every year their libraries of games expand, while old consoles fall by the wayside.