WaitingOnTheGame

A game like this with Total War style combat. make it happen Stardock.

▼

A game like this with Total War style combat. make it happen Stardock.

from Elemental Forums

In fact just cop the total war ui and graphic design as well and you are golden.

 

Just think of how cool that would be.

124,275 views 31 replies
Reply #26 from Elemental Forums Top

Quoting coyote303, reply 24

Paraphrasing the troll (he would want me to mention his name) replying to Reply 19 in his Reply 21:

Other game is so much better. Game's name sucks.

Sarcastic personal put down.

Game sucks.

Graphics suck.

Combat isn't sophisticated, therefore it sucks.

Strategic map sucks.

Combat format sucks.

Rambling conclusion further putting down the company.

 

I really don't understand the troll mentality. There are many games I don't like at all, but I certainly don't waste my time hanging out in their forums. It's both sad and funny at the same time.

 

"troll mentality" or "helpful and constructive criticism"?

 

I'm here because I care. It's better to have people express dislike than to have people fawn over the worthless nonstop.  Elemental did suck, did you play it?

Reply #27 from Elemental Forums Top

Quoting WaitingOnTheGame, reply 26
"troll mentality" or "helpful and constructive criticism"?

The answer is "troll mentality." There is nothing helpful nor constructive about Reply 21.

I'm here because I care.

While I cannot know your motivation for certain, I doubt this; evidence strongly suggests otherwise.

It's better to have people express dislike than to have people fawn over the worthless nonstop.

You are welcome to express your dislike, but don't insult us by claiming your motivations are pure or your comments are helpful. if you feel the game is worthless, you are wasting your time...unless, of course, you enjoy getting negative feedback such as this one.

My reply 24 also was not helpful nor constructive either, but it wasn't intended to be. It's goal was to point out how unhelpful, destructive, and ridiculous Reply 21 was.

Elemental did suck, did you play it?

I agree that Elemental was not a good game. I agree with your right to dislike (and to express your dislike of) Fallen Enchantress. I agree that helpful, constructive criticism can be a good thing. What I can't agree with you is that tearing something (or someone) down is helpful, constructive, or evidence that you care.

Galactic Civilizations III
Reply #28 from Elemental Forums Top

Quoting Stuie_, reply 9

You guys are crazy.  A fantasy Total War-style game would be awesome.  However, this (Elemental and kids) is not the starting point for something like that.  It would need to be built from the ground up.

 

You realize there already is one right?  The king arthur series is essentially total war with magic, mythical creatures and heroes

Reply #29 from Elemental Forums Top

AND it has champions embedded in units as well! I highly recommend the King Arthur series to everyone, it's great fun but its replayability is very low. I got maybe 30 hours out of the 1st one.

Reply #30 from Elemental Forums Top

Quoting coyote303, reply 27
The answer is "troll mentality." There is nothing helpful nor constructive about Reply 21.

 

I strongly disagree. I was saying that Stardock's formula and/or the implementation of their formula failed them, strongly. This is very true.

 

Quoting coyote303, reply 27
While I cannot know your motivation for certain, I doubt this; evidence strongly suggests otherwise.

Were you there when everyone was kissing Stardocks ass following the release of Elemental? Is that helpful?

 

Quoting coyote303, reply 27
You are welcome to express your dislike, but don't insult us by claiming your motivations are pure or your comments are helpful. if you feel the game is worthless, you are wasting your time...unless, of course, you enjoy getting negative feedback such as this one.

 

touche. To retort; my motivation is pure, and my comments are much stronger and more helpful than yours. I am fine with negative feedback.

 

Quoting coyote303, reply 27
My reply 24 also was not helpful nor constructive either, but it wasn't intended to be. It's goal was to point out how unhelpful, destructive, and ridiculous Reply 21 was.

 

I disagree with your appraisal of Reply 21



Quoting coyote303, reply 27
I agree that Elemental was not a good game. I agree with your right to dislike (and to express your dislike of) Fallen Enchantress. I agree that helpful, constructive criticism can be a good thing. What I can't agree with you is that tearing something (or someone) down is helpful, constructive, or evidence that you care.

I stated that the game was poor and then stated why it was poor. I didn't tear anyone down (in any tangibly unfair sense) in the slightest. Stardock knows that putting out good products will help them out. In the past they have shown a tendency to have a difficulty ascertaining the honest quality of their product. That is where we must help them.

 

This game has improved to the point where I would now rate it a solid 7/10. That is still pretty sh*tty.

 

There, I gave an honest appraisal.

Reply #31 from Elemental Forums Top

Quoting SkylanceFS, reply 28
You realize there already is one right? The king arthur series is essentially total war with magic, mythical creatures and heroes

 

Quoting Heavenfall, reply 29
AND it has champions embedded in units as well! I highly recommend the King Arthur series to everyone, it's great fun but its replayability is very low. I got maybe 30 hours out of the 1st one.

 

sounds good guys. I'll check it out.