Sethai Sethai

Population Control

Population Control

Given that environmental damage and resource consumption are proportional to the amount of human being on the planet, can population control techniques ever be ethical, justified or practical, and if so which techniques are fairest? How can population control be implemented without creating a gender imbalance? Must the operation of such programmes be implemented on a national basis, or is an international consensus required? Is it fair to say parents in developed countires (often with declining populations) should be limited to two children while families in booming developing nations continue to have 8?

While reproduction remains a fundamanetal human right, others might point out that many current human activities could constitute population control. For example, all food consumption effects food price, which goes on to effect family planning decisions around the world. In the above example, a family in america who choose to limit themselves to two children may, through changes in consumption, lead to a family elsewhere in the world having more. Can starvation ever be tolerated as the environments way of controlling population, as happens in many other ecosystems?

286,270 views 114 replies
Reply #51 Top

Throughout history there have been crossroads that mark the beginning and end of a certain era and/or lifestyle, etc.  For example, when one tribe/nation depleted its own resources, it went to war to take those of another tribe/nation.... attrition reduced population numbers  Nature has its own methods of attrition... plagues, famine, natural disasters, etc....

So yeah, the world as we know it is at another crossroad... mankind does not need to do anything... mother nature will enforce her own population control and we as a species will have to rebuild, perhaps not from scratch but from a less advanced state to where mankind sees itself today.

Whether or not any of us is around to see this I don't know, but it will happen... nature will provide the means to a more level playing field.

Reply #52 Top

Quoting navigatsio, reply 50
but realistically if I don't start with the man in the mirror and my own home, family, work and surroundings that I ACTUALLY DO have some control over what's the point except maybe some witty dialogue sprinkled here and there or possibly regurgitating something I heard that sounded thought provoking and clever...

Exactly...;)

It's not that hard to be even 'slightly' conscientious....

Don't buy a Prius....it costs the planet far more to make than it saves in petrol.

That'll do as a start....;)

Reply #53 Top

http://dieoff.org/synopsis.htm

Once oil production starts the terminal decline, a huge population die-off is inevitable anyway.

It's estimated that without fossil fuels, Earth cannot sustain more than 2 billions of people (probably less, considering how much we have already destroyed natural sources of food like fish, topsoil, etc.)

Reply #54 Top

Quoting Kamamura_CZ, reply 53
http://dieoff.org/synopsis.htm
Once oil production starts the terminal decline, a huge population die-off is inevitable anyway.

What sort of world would be left for the survivors though? How much sufferring must they go through first? Isn't it better that people not be born than die painful or humiliating deaths from starvation, disease or war?

As to how a sterilization policy would effect gender balance: surely if there is a culture of preferring boys then people will wait until they've had a boy before volunteering. So you get lots of families with either one boy or one girl and one boy, ie, a net male majority. Or is my probability maths just flawed?

Reply #56 Top

Quoting Sethai, reply 54

Quoting Kamamura_CZ, reply 53http://dieoff.org/synopsis.htm
Once oil production starts the terminal decline, a huge population die-off is inevitable anyway.


What sort of world would be left for the survivors though? How much sufferring must they go through first? Isn't it better that people not be born than die painful or humiliating deaths from starvation, disease or war?

As to how a sterilization policy would effect gender balance: surely if there is a culture of preferring boys then people will wait until they've had a boy before volunteering. So you get lots of families with either one boy or one girl and one boy, ie, a net male majority. Or is my probability maths just flawed?

You just look at it from a Western point of view. The ultrasound machine used in the west to diagnose disease is used in India to see the sex of the unborn child. Females are 'eliminated' by some because of economic considerations.

As to 'Sterilization Policy'? Smacks too much of Dr. Mengele, for me.

Alternatives? While available, our species is simply too insane and stupid to avail itself of logic, not destroying the earth, balancing need and supply, sustainability, etc.

The whole thread is rather pointless and 'Academic' because of that. Why ask "Why?"?

Reply #57 Top

Quoting starkers, reply 51
Throughout history there have been crossroads that mark the beginning and end of a certain era and/or lifestyle, etc.  For example, when one tribe/nation depleted its own resources, it went to war to take those of another tribe/nation.... attrition reduced population numbers  Nature has its own methods of attrition... plagues, famine, natural disasters, etc....

So yeah, the world as we know it is at another crossroad... mankind does not need to do anything... mother nature will enforce her own population control and we as a species will have to rebuild, perhaps not from scratch but from a less advanced state to where mankind sees itself today.

Whether or not any of us is around to see this I don't know, but it will happen... nature will provide the means to a more level playing field.

I wonder if you manage to keep this stoic view once the famines start and people around you will start killing each other for basic necessities like food and fuel. ... or if you will run an scream like the rest. Sure, the laws of physics will always lead to a solution - but it may be a solution you won't live to see. 

Reply #58 Top

Quoting Kamamura_CZ, reply 57
I wonder if you manage to keep this stoic view once the famines start and people around you will start killing each other for basic necessities like food and fuel. ... or if you will run an scream like the rest. Sure, the laws of physics will always lead to a solution - but it may be a solution you won't live to see.

It won't happen in my lifetime, I don't think, because basic resources have not as yet been depleted to the point of non-existence.  When fossil fuels have become a thing of the past and renewable energy sources cannot meet the demand, nature and society will implode.  Yes, nature will cull the human race to ensure its survival.

As for it being a stoic view, I tend to think it is a realistic view.. one that was precipitated by the greed of a handful of greedy corporate entities and self serving entrepreneurs. That's right, Capitalism will be the death of civilisation as we know it, sucking the life's blood from the planet and its inhabitants in their quest for exponential growth at any cost.  The fact is, there need not be shortages of food and basic needs at this point in history. 

There is still enough to go around, it's just that wealthy men/women have it concentrated to suit their own agendas while manipulating huge sections of population with shortages and gluts.... the shortages in places of high need, and the gluts in areas of lesser need... to justify wanton waste and its destruction when supply out-strips demand and profit is negated.

I mean, you don't think big business stores stuff for a rainy day, do you?  No, it costs them too much, so they cut their losses and tons and tons of food, clothing, etc gets destroyed, rather than donate it to the needy elsewhere.  No, there's no profit in doing that... and thousands of children in 3rd world countries die each week because greed in the 1st world is too great..

Reply #59 Top

There are plenty of population reductions mechanisms already implemented.  Ever heard of BPA or Biphenol-A?  You see those population control methods trickling down into the ecosystems of the animal kingdom causing considerable ecodamage to the planet.  Ironic no?  Frogs born with both sexes or next to no male equipment, fresh water fish now suffering the same problems, it is slowly getting worse and all in the name of population control whether intentional or not.  BPA is suspected to be responsible for the rise of homosexuality in men as well which only furthers population control.

Population control supporters scare the bajezzus out of me.  The 10:10 environmentalist video underlines this.

WARNING: IMO it's graphic

Reply #60 Top

ive been telling people in my social set since 1990 that Etheopia should have a population cull. (birth restriction) why would you even want to give birth to a child when you live in a nation that cant even feed its own, and depends on the good grace of other countries to help grow crops, set up wells, ect. its beyond me.

people might disagree, but every day of my life since i can remember ive seen ads on tv asking people in Australia to sponser children in Etheopia because they literally and i mean literally have no food, no water, no crops, and basically no homes (a slum is not a home to me) and no schooling.

basically nothing... so that is what i think they should have something in place for birth restriction...basically like china one child per couple.

Reply #61 Top

Quoting RogueCaptain, reply 59
WARNING: IMO it's graphic

'Tis a bit...but it'd probably actually work.....

...which is "unfortunate"....;p

The DeBono solution would be to 'Soylent Green' the dissenters rather than making quite so much 'mess'.

Reply #62 Top
Well, I think that to read all these messages make me more and more inquiring.
Having lived in Guadeloupe, this is an example, and to see all the population which runs(drives) 4x4 and big car there, to show, because now there is that çà which(who) counts: be better that the other one!
But these people there eat not in their hunger to be the best in front of the others!
The vacationers on Côte d'Azur, who come to spend on seeing the sea, and who do not care about their children, about their education, there is only to see where goes the world!
Then from there to say that we are in overpopulation and that it is necessary to become Génocidien to exterminate children still in the stomach of their mothers or not to feed the persons in Third World countries, it is necessary to stop(arrest) there!
To limit the control of the birth? Or is the freedom?
Ah yes I forgot that we are watched!
He(It) has have a good laugh there, let us come back from years behind,where families had many children, there was not at this moment
 
But everybody worked the earth(ground), ate healthily, and did not run(drive) with these big cars which consume some gasoline(essence) and some energy....
Then before speaking, becoming homosexuals, about abortions, to limit the overpopulation, think of your ancestors!

:X

 
 
Reply #63 Top

At the moment, why do not to accompany the countries which do not know the various means of contraception, to avoid arriving at extremes?

I one am had direct in my comments but I try to put myself in the place(square) of each and of course in mine..

 
Reply #64 Top

Birth control ...........

 

 

 
This child was not born yet in ..........
Did you think of it?
The women as the men(people) have their wrong(disadvantage) in this not deliberate situation..... But if she(it) is wished, or is the freedom
 
Reply #65 Top

<tinfoil hat>Control the food and you control the population.  Look at the majority of Africa.  You want to keep a people in check, and make sure they can't better themselves, starve them.  You can't think about much else when you're stomach is always empty.</tinfoil hat>

Reply #66 Top

Quoting Vampothika, reply 60
ive been telling people in my social set since 1990 that Etheopia should have a population cull. (birth restriction) why would you even want to give birth to a child when you live in a nation that cant even feed its own, and depends on the good grace of other countries to help grow crops, set up wells, ect. its beyond me.

What Ethiopia needs is for other countries to stop fucking about with them.  Leave them to their own devices and they'll figure it out.  Essentially, what all those commercials are doing is creating a continent of welfare losers like here in the states.  If you give someone money and food, specifically food in their case, what incentive do they have to help themselves?

And if some dimwit comes along and says, they haven't helped themselves yet, it's because for decades we've been fucking them over.  See my previous post.  I jest about the tinfoil hat thing but the post is true.

Reply #67 Top
The current situation of our world company(society) meets on the edge of the abyss, it is true that the overpopulation
 is for cause but the social education there also and a big awareness is outlined on the horizon... 
Between the good(property) and the evil put 10 nobody in 1 room(part,play) for 1 month,
 them shall try to take(bring) out there how together add 40 persons they shall destroy(annul)....
 And nevertheless it is easier in number to find a solution of exit(release).... 
The wisdom to find a solution of control of the overpopulation is evident, 
the question would be of that she(it) way by respecting our various civilization,
 customs, faiths, and development social economic so that together we can live correctly in the respect for the existence
But the current state of the humanity stops(arrests) not only in an overpopulation because the enormous
 imbalance between nations is there in the front line... 
The resources are often exploited(run) in third countries for our personal needs 
and in more after their credit note quite drawn we go their to impose a control of the population?... 
Has for a problem of consciousness There... Weapons, wars, conflicts, incomprehension between the cultures of the peoples etc. 
we would have it whole pages to be written but we forget to love his(her) fellow man. 
We forget it to find solutions together in the good(property)
 to be and the wisdom of the life which we in summer datum as long as we so show ourselves 
as I read on some I find disgusting to see people with so much hatred in their comments...
Sincerely in the IT era which we live, the union makes it a rule to find a sense(direction) of the solutions in the good(property)
 and the voucher which we have inside us.
The birth of the UNO
In June 26th, 1945 - During both world wars, it is as nothing could more prevent the violence
 from submerging the planet that took shape the attempts of universal organization of the peace, 
as if the peoples had needed to look beyond the abyss which they could not avoid any more.

However new is the union of the government of our planet which of climatic order does not support(bear) 
us any more the question of our overpopulation already reached(affected) 
at present is to have to check(control) not only but to find necessarily a solution of the current state, 
humanely in the good(property) by taking into account everything.
We are going all to have to without exceptions change our lifestyle. Because the climate of our planet will not give us of time(weather).
The social, economic consequences and the movement of the population are inevitable.
At the same time as an awareness of our current overpopulation we have to learn to live differed lies.
And then establish a control of the population in compliance with rules of socioeconomic healthy life beyond our countries and continents.
With a balance which takes into account everything the politicoreligieux parameters of the nations in the properties(goods)
 
We have economically and really the means which the whole world eats in its hunger and gives itself
 the possibility of evolving correctly on our planet
The costs attributed(awarded) to the wars and have our safety(security) are more enormous than a discution to find solutions peace-loving person.
The resources of our planet are still suitable if we stop deceiving it.
Our strength in the union is also big as in our destruction.
But openly humbly simply of credit note became aware to refuse to my wife to have a child 
I rebel on certain comment as I continue of quote and know that better to spread the evil consciously
 it's better to remain humble in front of the existence because our fellow man will have no more what we destroyed(annulled)
Reply #68 Top

Quoting <span><span>lecajef</span></span>, reply 67
La situation actuelle de notre société du monde (la société) se réunit sur le bord de l'abîme, il est vrai que la surpopulation
est pour cause, mais l'éducation sociale et il ya aussi une prise de conscience est la taille décrite à l'horizon ...
Entre le bien (propriété) et le mal de mettre 10 personne dans une chambre (une partie, le jeu) pour un mois,
eux doit essayer de prendre (apporter) là-bas comment, ensemble, ajouter 40 personnes, ils doivent détruire (annuler )....
Et pourtant il est plus facile en nombre pour trouver une solution de sortie (sortie ).... 
La sagesse de trouver une solution de contrôle de la surpopulation est évidente, 
la question serait de ce qu'elle (il) façon en respectant notre civilisation diverses,
coutumes, les religions, et le développement socio-économique afin qu'ensemble nous puissions vivre correctement dans le respect de l'existence
Mais l'état actuel de l'humanité cesse (arrestations), non seulement dans une surpopulation à cause de l'énorme
déséquilibre entre les nations est là, dans la ligne de front ... 
Les ressources sont souvent exploités (courir) dans les pays tiers pour nos besoins personnels 
et en plus après leur note de crédit très élaboré nous allons leur imposer un contrôle de la population? ... 
A pour un problème de conscience ... Il Armes, les guerres, les conflits, l'incompréhension entre les cultures des peuples etc 
nous aurions des pages entières à écrire, mais on oublie de l'amour de son (sa) prochain. 
Nous l'oublier pour trouver des solutions ensemble dans la bonne (bien)
d'être et de la sagesse de la vie qui nous en donnée d'été aussi longtemps que nous avons si nous montrer 
que j'ai lu sur certains je trouve dégoûtant de voir des gens avec tant de haine dans leurs commentaires ...
Sincèrement à l'ère informatique où nous vivons, le syndicat fait une règle pour trouver un sens (direction) des solutions dans le bon ( propriété)
et le voucher que nous avons en nous.
La naissance de l'ONU
En Juin 26th, 1945 - Au cours des deux guerres mondiales, c'est comme rien ne pouvait plus empêcher la violence
à partir de submerger la planète qui a pris forme les tentatives d'organisation universelle de la paix, 
comme si les peuples avaient besoin de regarder au-delà de l'abîme où ils ne pouvaient pas éviter de plus. Mais de nouvelles est l'union du gouvernement de notre planète, qui de l'ordre climatiques ne supporte pas (l'ours) 


plus nous la question de la surpopulation de notre déjà atteint (affectées) 
à l'heure actuelle est d'avoir à vérifier (contrôle), mais pas seulement de trouver nécessairement une solution de l'état actuel, 
humainement dans la bonne (bien) en prenant en compte tout ce.
Nous allons tous devoir sans exceptions changer notre mode de vie. Parce que le climat de notre planète ne va pas nous donner du temps (météo).
Les conséquences sociales, économiques et le mouvement de la population sont inévitables.
Dans le même temps comme une prise de conscience de notre surpopulation actuelle, nous devons apprendre à vivre différait mensonges.
Et puis établir un contrôle de la population dans le respect des règles de vie saines socioéconomiques delà de nos pays et continents.
Avec un solde qui prend en compte les paramètres tout politicoreligieux des nations dans les propriétés (biens)
 
Nous avons vraiment économiquement et les moyens dont le monde entier mange à sa faim et se donne
la possibilité d'évoluer correctement sur ​​notre planète
Les coûts attribués (attribué) pour les guerres et avons notre sécurité (la sécurité) sont plus énormes que une discution pour trouver des solutions pacifiques personne.
Les ressources de notre planète sont encore adaptés si l'on cesse de tromper elle.
Notre force dans l'union est aussi grand que dans notre destruction.
Mais ouvertement avec humilité tout simplement de la note de crédit ont pris conscience de refuser à ma femme d'avoir un enfant 
J'ai rebelles sur certains commentaires que je continue de citer et savez mieux pour répandre le mal consciemment
il est préférable de rester humble face à l'existence, car notre prochain n'aura plus de ce que nous avons détruit (annulé)

 

 

Respect à toi mon mari,

La vie commence comme çà, se respecter les uns les autres, et savoir s'apprécier à notre juste valeur, aider son prochain comme on peut s'aider soi-même.......................

Reply #69 Top

Porter le monde comme on peut porter la vie, ne pas se faire de mal, et se respecter.......................................

 

Reply #70 Top


What Ethiopia needs is for other countries to stop fucking about with them.  Leave them to their own devices and they'll figure it out.  Essentially, what all those commercials are doing is creating a continent of welfare losers like here in the states.  If you give someone money and food, specifically food in their case, what incentive do they have to help themselves?

And if some dimwit comes along and says, they haven't helped themselves yet, it's because for decades we've been fucking them over.  See my previous post.  I jest about the tinfoil hat thing but the post is true.[/quote]

But how to be also inhuman you...

Reply #71 Top
thiopia
A wonderful country which shows has this only place the existance of the birth of the world... Tribes armed(equipped) by our economy to destroy(annul) itself between them..
Reply #72 Top

Quoting <span><span>natas2</span></span>, reply 66

Citant Vampothika, Répondre 60Ive été de dire aux gens dans mon cercle social depuis 1990 que Etheopia devrait avoir une réforme de la population. (Limitation des naissances), pourquoi voudriez-vous pour donner naissance à un enfant quand on vit dans une nation qui ne peut même nourrir sa propre et dépend de la bonne grâce d'autres pays pour aider à pousser des cultures, mettre en place des puits, etc. sa me dépasse.

Que l'Ethiopie a besoin, c'est pour d'autres pays pour arrêter putain sujet avec eux. Laissez-les à leurs propres moyens et ils vont comprendre. Essentiellement, ce que toutes ces publicités sont en train de créer un continent de perdants bien-être comme ici dans les états. Si vous donnez l'argent à quelqu'un et de la nourriture, particulièrement la nourriture dans leur cas, quel intérêt ont-ils s'aider eux-mêmes?

Et si certains imbécile arrive et dit, ils ne se sont pas encore aidé, c'est parce que pendant des décennies nous avons été les baiser plus. Voir mon post précédent. Je plaisante au sujet de la chose chapeau en aluminium, mais le message est vrai.

 

 

 

With due respect, you were only once in the embarrassment? Financial embarrassment, or lack of food?
I do not think, because you will not hold offensive comments how you utter them!
Whether it is Ethiopia, France, Africa, India or America, every person has some blood which flows(sinks) into its veins ......
We are every equals in front of the life, regrettably so a lot of nobody think as you, how the world can get(fit) better!!!!!

 

 
Reply #74 Top

Quoting <span><span>Jafo</span></span>, reply 48
Un tag-team de "mari et femme» en français ne correspond pas à un débat, mais se propage plutôt une certaine forme de dissidence de la famille.

Peut-être faites chaque tentative d'utiliser la langue par défaut du site, s'il vous plaît.

 


Citant militante, Répondre 31Pourquoi (et comment) dois-je changer pour rendre la vie meilleure pour les gens dans ce continent primitif? Ils sont ceux qui n'ont pas atteint une chose putain! Ils sont ceux qui ne peuvent pas se nourrir! Faire des tonnes de gosses mais ne peut pas feed'em ... Real Smart ....

Encore une fois avec le «nous et eux».

«Ils n'ont pas réalisé une chose foutue"? "Ils" ont colonisé votre pays [probables]. "Ils" sont morts ainsi votre appareil des entreprises peuvent tirer profit [Union Carbide].

"Ils" travaillent pour un salaire merde vous pouvez donc avoir bon [er] Nikes.

Ils ne voient pas le droit de porter les armes [posséder une arme] supérieur au droit d'accès aux soins médicaux.

Ils n'encouragent pas les déchets et les abus des ressources naturelles à travers la basale convoitise pour la richesse et la démesure.

Descendez vos ânes collective et faire quelque chose, quelque chose vers réduisant votre impact sur les ressources limitées de la planète.

Si vous avez besoin de demander «comment», alors vous êtes la cause perdue dans la société de ce monde.

 

You say anything and disappoint me profoundly...

Reply #75 Top
PRESS CONFERENCE ON THE LEVEL OF THE WORLD POPULATION ON THE HORIZON 2100, WHICH WILL DEPEND ON POLITICS(POLICIES) TAKEN BY COUNTRIES WITH STRONG FERTILITY

The world population should reach(affect) 7 billions this year, 9,3 in 2050 and 10,1 billions in 2100, indicates a report(relationship) presented today by United Nations
Edited to be extract only. Original source unspecified/unknown. [Admin]