DrJBHL DrJBHL

Windows 8 MS Preview - How Will WB Work on This?

Windows 8 MS Preview - How Will WB Work on This?

 

If I don’t succeed in getting the YouTube Vid into this, the vid and article appear on Lifehacker’s  homepage.

It poses a very interesting question… what’s going to happen to skinning with the advent of Windows 8 on PC’s?

You see, There isn’t a Start Menu and taskbar, nor traditional windows. There’s a Start Page, and basically a Smart Phone interface with tiles and the weather tile appears to be a widget.

So what do you think?

 

To me at least, this diverges a good deal from prior build leaked (and employees fired) where there was a traditional taskbar and orb. Now it looks like they're using "Tiles" or an equivalent with a Winflag button (replacing the orb) to return to the Start Page...

There were other buttons (on the right side on the "Tiles" type bar or dock) but their function wasn't demo'd. 

123,763 views 73 replies
Reply #26 Top

Quoting gmc2, reply 20
per Jafo's post it looks like there are still alot of xp users
End of gmc2's quote

Looking at those numbers the 'drift' is about 4% per month.

That's likely to level out [that bell curve thingie] but XP is definitely a dying market....;)

Reply #27 Top

it won't work for real computers, can you imagine the changes people would have to do?!

the first time my parents gets on it and they look at me and say "Where is the start button?" and then ditch it to go back to xp or vista or 7 (funny my family has all 3 os)

Even the mac lion's iOS homescreen design isn't driving tons of people to use that features, we love the way we use our computers we control what icons goes on our desktop. what we see on it and we definitely don't want to use IE.

Reply #28 Top

Quoting LightStar, reply 25

Quoting Frogboy, reply 10It's the immersive UI mode of Windows 8.  Great for tablets just like Media Center experience is good in its way too.

 

Thanks for the clarification Brad, phew!

 
End of LightStar's quote

Tom... much has come out about this new OS which is still being built. One thing is clear, though: This is for PC's with touch screen capabilities as well as for Tablets as MS has clearly said so. They also said it will work with keyboards and mice as well.

What is not clear is whether/how the taskbar/orb will work. I read here: http://www.neowin.net/news/microsoft-windows-8-is-the-biggest-shift-in-design-since-win-95  that the orb and bar exist "under" the new start screen. I'm willing to believe it, but I didn't see it in the demo, unless the dock like thing from the right part of the screen is a "taskbar" or taskdock....

Maybe it'll be skinnable. Maybe not. Not that much is clear from the rather limited video. Maybe the bar that comes in from the left will also be skinnable. Maybe the icons too. But this much is clear: It's a MAJOR change, and it's not just for touch screen devices: MS said so.

It's not by accident they put together their new "gesture" mouse, and I'm betting there'll be a special keyboard as well.

Reply #29 Top

Quoting DrJBHL, reply 23
depends whether you have programs solely suited to XP
End of DrJBHL's quote

I have a few games that I'd like to play that would be for XP and also skinning the OS for those that still do.

I'm going back to the drawing board with metalwerks to include xp. I have some templates and older blinds to draw info from.

Reply #30 Top

Quoting gmc2, reply 29
Quoting DrJBHL, reply 23depends whether you have programs solely suited to XP

I have a few games that I'd like to play that would be for XP and also skinning the OS for those that still do.

I'm going back to the drawing board with metalwerks to include xp. I have some templates and older blinds to draw info from.
End of gmc2's quote

Not sure the games will work... because of the drivers on your computer - are W7, not XP... you can always try.

Reply #31 Top

Quoting Frogboy, reply 8
I thought Windows XP was going to kill Stardock. No wait, Vista for sure. Ok. Windows 7 then..

Incidentally, this is a demo of Windows 8 for tablets.
End of Frogboy's quote

That is a good use.  As long as they keep the menus in for the regular computers, it will be interesting to play with.

Reply #32 Top

I think the choice I will be faced with in the future is what do I WANT and what do I NEED in an operating system. This new interface seems attractive. One the other hand customizing and skinning are part of the things I really enjoy doing on my computer so if an older, function able version of windows still allows me to get my fix and get done what I need to get done then I will probably stay with that until something more attractive lures me away. Windows 8, by that video clip, probably won't do it.

Reply #33 Top

This from engadget:

"There'll be two kinds of applications for Windows 8, one that runs in a traditional desktop, and the other pseudo-mobile apps based on HTML5 and Javascript, but both environments -- rather, the entire OS -- have been designed from the ground up for touchscreen use. Keyboard and mouse will still be options for both sets of programs, but there are multiple virtual sets of keys for different form factors, including a split keyboard for vertical slate use. Multitasking is simply a matter of swiping running apps into the center of the screen, and you can pull windows partway to "snap" them in place alongside other windows -- even mixing and matching traditional desktop programs with web apps simultaneously (like Twitter alongside your spreadsheet). There's a new version of Internet Explorer 10 (which runs Silverlight) and an app store built into the touchscreen interface, along with integrated services like Office 365. Microsoft says the new OS will run on laptops, tablets and desktops when it appears -- whenever that might be." - Sean Hollister, engadget

Thus it would seem if Mr. Hollister is correct, WB has a bright future even with Windows8. And I do hope he's right! :)

 

Reply #34 Top

Okay, hold on a second there Doc, let me fasten my seatbelt, this looks like it's going to be a wild ride with Windows 8.   :rolleyes: :O *_* :rofl:

Reply #35 Top

Wow, I'm actually surprised at all the negative comments about a product that is nowhere near completion and in reality seems pretty cool compared to what we have today. Even more so I find it interesting how so many people take shots at MS's softwares when a great majority still use Windows in some fashion. My only conclusion as to why so many still have XP is because in most cases they simply either have not updated their PCs because they see no point in buying a new OS for an old PC when they probably plan on getting a new one or already got a new one or they have no clue they can update their PCs to Windows 7 as oppose to having to buy a new one. This conclusion is drawn from the fact that most people that I know who own a PC know very little about PCs, installing software, updating or replacing hardware or even how anything works. Most only know how to navigate IE to facebook and such sites and have little clue as to how the Internet works at all.

 

Reply #36 Top

Quoting DrJBHL, reply 33
This from engadget:

"There'll be two kinds of applications for Windows 8, one that runs in a traditional desktop, and the other pseudo-mobile apps based on HTML5 and Javascript, but both environments -- rather, the entire OS -- have been designed from the ground up for touchscreen use.
End of DrJBHL's quote

I was just going to make that observation (having read more about Win8). For some, it is really a good idea.  I know my mother would be a lot less confused with fewer choices.  But for many of us here on this forum - it is going to suck big time!  I wonder if MS is really coming up with a new ME?  At this point, I do not like what I read.  But perhaps when it is released it will have what I want and need as well.

Reply #37 Top

I think I'll opt to keep 7 as long as I can on this computer and put 8 on my touchscreen... I'll opt to run the orb and bar for most things, and the rest will go to the touchscreen....

Reply #38 Top

Quoting DrJBHL, reply 37
I think I'll opt to keep 7 as long as I can on this computer and put 8 on my touchscreen... I'll opt to run the orb and bar for most things, and the rest will go to the touchscreen....
End of DrJBHL's quote

or on your smartphone?  Me thinks that is what 8 is aimed for (and the articles I read seemed to insinuate that as well).

Reply #39 Top

There's a lot more cell phones and smartphones and what have you than PC's or laptops methinks. Bigger market. OS goes for about the same price but two to three times the profit. Just guessing.

Reply #40 Top

Quoting Uvah, reply 39
There's a lot more cell phones and smartphones and what have you than PC's or laptops methinks. Bigger market. OS goes for about the same price but two to three times the profit. Just guessing.
End of Uvah's quote

Except in my house - we got 2 cell phones - but we also have 6 computers (one we use as a file server) ;)

Reply #41 Top

Quoting Dr, reply 40
Quoting Uvah, reply 39There's a lot more cell phones and smartphones and what have you than PC's or laptops methinks. Bigger market. OS goes for about the same price but two to three times the profit. Just guessing.

Except in my house - we got 2 cell phones - but we also have 6 computers (one we use as a file server)
End of Dr's quote

Per MS, it's aimed at everything you both mentioned. How's that for Moderating? LOL.

Truly though, in all the references through the thread which I've given, it's aimed at all platforms.... and Dr Guy's house presents a major electromagnetic hazard. I figure the Aliens have detected earth only because of him. Fie on thee, Sir Guy of Megahertz!

Reply #42 Top

There's a start menu analogue at 1:31.

Additionally, at 3:08, it switches to normal windows, which to me suggests that this whole thing is just an app environment pasted over Windows 7.

Reply #43 Top

Nope. It's not a layer. Definitely not. Check out some of my links.

Reply #44 Top

It got me a bit worried, since the current school of thought at Microsoft seems to be 'backwards compatibility be damned' (one of the major reasons why Vista was such a flop, although I personally used it and liked it).

On the other hand, touch is great for iPads and the like, but I for one wouldn't like to get finger grease on my 30" monitors (well, I suppose I could always wash my hands first) XD

Reply #45 Top

Quoting JcRabbit, reply 44
On the other hand, touch is great for iPads and the like, but I for one wouldn't like to get finger grease on my 30" monitors (well, I suppose I could always wash my hands first)
End of JcRabbit's quote

Which is why you should be buying "Windex futures"!

Jorge, apparently there'll be a way to use the old orb/taskbar although I didn't actually see it in the video....

Reply #46 Top

Quoting Jafo, reply 14


 

Not a lot of Win7 sales?

That's the current stats for OS usage....
End of Jafo's quote

 

I specified RETAIL sales for a reason. I would say the majority of win 7 users are running win 7 OEM models preloaded with new PCS (or purched OEM copies either way its not retail versions).

At retail windows is always a slow seller with their pricing(not hard to figure out why when a retail copy of windows 7 isn't much cheaper than a brand new netbook  or cheap laptop with win 7 preloaded). Either way my major point was that any retail sales of windows 7 there may or may not be are likely to die off with the release of windows 8 retail copies.

Reply #47 Top

Quoting Fistalis, reply 46
I specified RETAIL sales for a reason. I would say the majority of win 7 users are running win 7 OEM models preloaded with new PCS (or purched OEM copies either way its not retail versions). At retail windows is always a slow seller with their pricing.
End of Fistalis's quote

It doesn't matter how you wish to qualify the stats...the reality is XP use is a dwindling % and Win7 is in growth.  Whether OEM or Retail the OS IS ACTUALLY PURCHASED.

In my case none of the systems running Win7 is either OEM OR Retail.  I've never purchased Win 7.  The 2 XP installs are OEM [though one wasn't 'technically' OEM in that it wasn't on a system at the time of purchase].

In case you're wondering...the 5 installs of Win 7 are via Technet ...;)

Reply #48 Top

Quoting Jafo, reply 47

Quoting Fistalis, reply 46I specified RETAIL sales for a reason. I would say the majority of win 7 users are running win 7 OEM models preloaded with new PCS (or purched OEM copies either way its not retail versions). At retail windows is always a slow seller with their pricing.
It doesn't matter how you wish to qualify the stats...the reality is XP use is a dwindling % and Win7 is in growth.  Whether OEM or Retail the OS IS ACTUALLY PURCHASED.

In my case none of the systems running Win7 is either OEM OR Retail.  I've never purchased Win 7.  The 2 XP installs are OEM [though one wasn't 'technically' OEM in that it wasn't on a system at the time of purchase].

In case you're wondering...the 5 installs of Win 7 are via Technet ...
End of Jafo's quote

 

So lets see if I got this straight.

 I say win 7 retail sales were poor.

You say but look at all the people using windows 7.

And i say... yes but those were't retail sales.

and you say ya so what...

lol non sequitur much?

 

Anyway my major point was simply that (yes i'll say it again) any retail sales of 7 will quickly die off and be replaced by win 8 sales on release.(not only retail but new PCS will be coming loaded with win 8 instead). If win 7 users are unlikely to upgrade so soon.. and xp levels off where are the sales of win 8 gonna come from? (again horrible retail sales) pre loaded PCs.

 

End note: Dwindling or not 40% of users using xp is still a large chunk of the market. Even if it were to level off at 30% of users its still a large chunk of end users and ignoring support for apps/games for xp in the near future is liable to cost sales no matter how you look at it. The faster MS pushes out new OS the less often people are likely to upgrade. Here in 2 or 3 years people with vista are going to be told they are in the dinosaur days because they haven't paid MS for windows 8. lol its a never ending upgrade cycle and the more stable OS are going to continue being used longer into each cycle.  Which is why XP still holds such a sway.. and win 7 will probably hold a similar chunk in the future while MS is pushing windows 9 and directX 14.

The question as a consumer comes down to why upgrade every 2 or 3 years.. when you can wait and for the same price as that new upgrade you can just upgrade further every 10 or 12 years. (leap frogging a few of the versions for the sake of saving the cash). Which is where I'm at personally.. why would I upgrade to 7 when 8 is on the horizon?

(granted I may be abnormal since I've never really understood the whole "I need that new thing right now so I can sell it and buy the next new thing next year" mentality many people have these days. Post modern consumerism? lol)

Reply #49 Top

Quoting Fistalis, reply 48
Which is where I'm at personally.. why would I upgrade to 7 when 8 is on the horizon?
End of Fistalis's quote

Because 7 actually works properly.

No other MS OS ever did....;)

 

Nothing in those stats indicates that XP will level off at 30.  ALL prior OS versions simply decline in use/popularity until they're essentially irrelevant.

Reply #50 Top

Fistalis, the stats are clear... the movement to 7 is coming from the dwindling XP user percentage. True, there is still a very large percentage of XP in the user population but that's also a function of businesses (still on XP because of the poor economy and lack of popular knowledge of W7 in the work force, and not wanting/affording upgrade of machines and peripherals) and of the economy - more people are trying to 'make do'... just as you state. The stats also make no mention at all of the mobile market... in which XP is zero. I agree with Jafo, as well: XP will disappear because the machines are growing older and because W7 is a much better OS.

I think that when/if the economy recovers significantly, the W7/XP balance will shift more quickly and radically. Since the mobile market isn't represented, then the stats don't reflect the 'true' market share of the OS's, as OEM will be 100% there, and the other mobile platforms aren't even mentioned. My guess is that the stats only represent PC's and laptops and they are far from the whole market: Tablets, netbooks, etc. are a significant part of OEM sales, now. I think retail sales will be dropping in the future for all OS's... and I don't like the "Buy a new one every two years" mentality, either.

This whole new OS thing every 2-3 years is absurd. They should be making patches/upgrades more frequently and cheaper. There should be more effort being put into uninstalling the 'older' parts of the OS's and making them more modern if the hardware can tolerate the change. People should also understand "futurizing" PC's, etc. at the time of purchase.