Frogboy Frogboy

Fallen Enchantress, a new game

Fallen Enchantress, a new game

“Expansion Packs”

AirShrineSceneIn the time before digital distribution, you had “expansion packs”. It is a concept that has survived well into the digital distribution age.

You’d release say Galactic Civilizations II: Dark Avatar as an expansion for people who had the game and then Galactic Civilizations II: Gold Edition for new buyers.  Similarly, we released Sins of a Solar Empire: Diplomacy and Sins of a solar Empire: Trinity for new buyers. 

So why was that done? The answer is, in the old days, there was no sure fire way to tell if someone had the original game. So you had to offer a second SCU just for those people.  On the business software side, all kinds of efforts have been made to try to get new editions down to a single SCU including installers that sniffed for the original version, send in a copy of your manual, you name it.

A New Team

Fallen Enchantress gives us the opportunity to have a very different fantasy strategy game than War of Magic. While the original intent was simply to eliminate an unnecessary SCU (we can simply have Fallen Enchantress with an upgrade price for people who have War of Magic), in this case, it lets us make an even bigger break from War of Magic because it has a new Lead Designer (Kael instead of myself) with Jon Shafer helping as well as we begin pre-production of Jon’s new game along with many other changes. It’s still Stardock but it’s a very different Stardock than what made War of Magic (or GalCiv II for that matter).

I’m still filling the role of studio lead developer and Executive Producer but we’re actively seeking out industry veterans to take over the role of lead developer of Stardock Entertainment.

A New Game

There is also another advantage to Fallen Enchantress being its own game rather than an “expansion pack”. And that is, it frees the team to make radical changes to the basics of the game while allowing War of Magic to still be updated on its own source tree.  A user of Fallen Enchantress won’t have to have War of Magic to play it and can treat War of Magic as a separate game.

This will be the same case for the third entry in the Elemental world which won’t be out for a long time still (but will be free for people who got War of Magic before the end of October 2010).  It’ll be its own game as well not requiring War of Magic and Fallen Enchantress but be available at a sharp discount to those who have the previous entries in the game world.

The Changing Market

A few years ago, this wouldn’t be possible. Retailers would have refused to carry just stand-alone expansion. There were exceptions and the Company of Heroes series did a lot of good for our industry by paving the way here. Supreme Commander’s “stand alone” expansion helps as well. 

Of course, no one has brought more attention to the changing digital model of PC games more than Blizzard with its recent release of Starcraft 2: Wings of Liberty which will have two additional stand-alone games in the Starcraft 2 universe. 

Will this be a good thing for PC gamers? I think it depends on how it’s handled. Personally, I’d like to see people get discounts if they have other chapters in the series. That’s going to be our model for the foreseeable future but part of that is because we have our own digital distribution platform (Impulse).

703,299 views 201 replies
Reply #51 Top

Also based on the press release, it looks like they are really ramping up the RGP elements of the game. Not at the expense of the TBS aspect of the game, I hope.

Reply #53 Top

I think you guys miss the point

If the classify it as a second game and never make an expansion for War of Magic that means the sales pitch they gave everyoen in December that if you guy the game before the end of the year you get the first expansion free has been null envoid and you get nothing for free.

I think you are the only one here that is worried about that as it is deffo not the case.

I think what people are questioning is the fact that FE (Fallen Enchantress) is being introduced as a new game (possibly with the removal of some WoM play rules) not as an update with additional functionality/content on top of the base WoM (War of Magic), so therefore if you prefer the gameplay of 1.20 WoM you will not be able to play that with the additional content from FE.

Then when the 2nd expansion comes out will that be a modification of WoM again or FE?

I hope that makes sense

Now I'm not that concerned as I trust Brad, Derek and Jon's ability to make the right decisions.

This sums up how i feel brilliantly. As long as each new game carrys over the bulk of the content from the previous ones I am happy.

Reply #54 Top

Quoting Lothos, reply 49
I think you guys miss the point

If the classify it as a second game and never make an expansion for War of Magic that means the sales pitch they gave everyoen in December that if you guy the game before the end of the year you get the first expansion free has been null envoid and you get nothing for free.

What in essence they can do is now claim this new game as a new game and re-charge everyone for what really is the expansion for War of Magic and never have to keep their promise of having an expansion. They are not very clear on this and in essence this could be clasified as fraud. I specifically purchased Elemental for Christmas even though I knew the game was buggy and unplayable because of their offer and now with this unique wording they are resinding the offer (well it appears they may try since they are not clear). I have no problem contacting the Maryland State Attorney Generals office if this is the case. Done it with LucasArts so I don't see how this will be different but it just depends on what their intentions are. If they just want literall a stand alone expansion and use it still to honor their agreement with everyone who bought the game during the holidays then I am fine with that and will be happy.

Well Stardock might be able to do that but it'd be akin to committing business suicide and extremely bad PR.

I appreciate the concern but I think there is a 0% chance of the happening.

Reply #55 Top

I'm not sure why you are all so confused...they are releasing the enchantress as a stand alone expansion.  They will continue to update war of magic with advancements they make for the enchantress to a point. And you get that expansion for free if you bought it before christmass...so...no one is asking for your "money".

 

The game is not going in the dustbin, since it is an expansion of the original.  I'm willing to bet you don't have to download the whole new expansion, but you will patch your current version.

Reply #56 Top

Quoting aeligos, reply 40
Frogboy,

I am actively promoting Elemental/Stardock, and I was asked if a DEMO or TRIAL version was available for this game...

Any plans on making one?  If so, when?

I'd like to give them your answer on this.

Thanks!

-.-

 

Me too. I have a number of friends that don't live close to me that would be interested in buying but they'd like to try a demo first.

Perhaps after 1.20 would be the logical time methinks.

Reply #57 Top

Quoting Lothos, reply 49
I think you guys miss the point

If the classify it as a second game and never make an expansion for War of Magic that means the sales pitch they gave everyoen in December that if you guy the game before the end of the year you get the first expansion free has been null envoid and you get nothing for free.

What in essence they can do is now claim this new game as a new game and re-charge everyone for what really is the expansion for War of Magic and never have to keep their promise of having an expansion. They are not very clear on this and in essence this could be clasified as fraud. I specifically purchased Elemental for Christmas even though I knew the game was buggy and unplayable because of their offer and now with this unique wording they are resinding the offer (well it appears they may try since they are not clear). I have no problem contacting the Maryland State Attorney Generals office if this is the case. Done it with LucasArts so I don't see how this will be different but it just depends on what their intentions are. If they just want literall a stand alone expansion and use it still to honor their agreement with everyone who bought the game during the holidays then I am fine with that and will be happy.

 

Only one person missing the point here.

 

Reply #58 Top

Quoting Rune_74, reply 55
I'm not sure why you are all so confused...they are releasing the enchantress as a stand alone expansion.  They will continue to update war of magic with advancements they make for the enchantress to a point. And you get that expansion for free if you bought it before christmass...so...no one is asking for your "money".

 

The game is not going in the dustbin, since it is an expansion of the original.  I'm willing to bet you don't have to download the whole new expansion, but you will patch your current version.

It is not so much confusion. I am 95% sure you are right with what you say there. But the announcement could be and has been (as is evident by the comments in this thread) interpetated a few different ways. While "common sense" and past experience with stardock suggests you are correct a little more clarification would go along way. It's no biggy I am sure all will be revealed in time.

Reply #59 Top

Quoting Lothos, reply 49
I think you guys miss the point

If the classify it as a second game and never make an expansion for War of Magic that means the sales pitch they gave everyoen in December that if you guy the game before the end of the year you get the first expansion free has been null envoid and you get nothing for free.

Can't imagine Stardock doing that and I'm sure they have no intention of. The potential gain of a bit of money would be nothing compared to the the horrible PR and very angry fans. In any case, Brad has said that Stardock is actually prepared to lose money on Elemental to gain back the trust of those unhappy with the release state of Elemental.

How many other gaming companies offer free expansions due to an unsatisfactory release? Never seen that from EA or anywhere else...

Reply #60 Top

Quoting Lothos, reply 49
I think you guys miss the point

If the classify it as a second game and never make an expansion for War of Magic that means the sales pitch they gave everyoen in December that if you guy the game before the end of the year you get the first expansion free has been null envoid and you get nothing for free.

What in essence they can do is now claim this new game as a new game and re-charge everyone for what really is the expansion for War of Magic and never have to keep their promise of having an expansion. They are not very clear on this and in essence this could be clasified as fraud. I specifically purchased Elemental for Christmas even though I knew the game was buggy and unplayable because of their offer and now with this unique wording they are resinding the offer (well it appears they may try since they are not clear). I have no problem contacting the Maryland State Attorney Generals office if this is the case. Done it with LucasArts so I don't see how this will be different but it just depends on what their intentions are. If they just want literall a stand alone expansion and use it still to honor their agreement with everyone who bought the game during the holidays then I am fine with that and will be happy.

But if you read the press release which i quoted in a response to you above it states that THIS IS the free expansion advertised. Your just tripping out without getting the facts.

So AGAIN i will quote the news post on this subject and even provide you a handy link to it.

 

"Elemental: Fallen Enchantress is expected to be released in the Summer of 2011. It will be free to those who purchased Elemental: War of Magic in 2010 and be available at a significant discount for those who purchase War of Magic."

It can be found here

https://forums.elementalgame.com/403846

 

Further more its apparent you aren't even reading anything posted here because I already pointed this out and explained it once in response to your crazy arse claims. So for the sake of everyone involved, if you choose to participate in a discussion.. actually participate in it.  That means reading as well as writing.

 

Reply #61 Top

Confusion or not... can't blame people for asking these questions; the announcement is certainly worded very peculiarly.

 

Quoting Belwolvie, reply 47

I think what people are questioning is the fact that FE (Fallen Enchantress) is being introduced as a new game (possibly with the removal of some WoM play rules) not as an update with additional functionality/content on top of the base WoM (War of Magic), so therefore if you prefer the gameplay of 1.20 WoM you will not be able to play that with the additional content from FE.

 

Thank you.  You indeed nailed it perfectly (far better than some who attempted clarifying this).

Reply #62 Top

Quoting Freebird1956, reply 15
I`m now confused ? I thought we were fixing the original game ? I understand the concept of a new game. Lets make the first group of purchasers happy. I`m one of those people. Make me happy that I bought your game in the firstplace. I will then consider making another purchase from Statdock. If I`m wrong in my thinking please let me know. Just for the record, I do feel that Stardock is heading in the right direction. Having great co-workers is going to be a plus. I see great things happenning at Stardock. I just want a complete follow thru before we start asking for another purchase. Thank you ...........

Freebird out of the birdcage for the moment.

You get Fallen Enchantress for free. And if you were one of the first purchasers, you get the next one free too.

Reply #63 Top

Quoting Frogboy, reply 62
You get Fallen Enchantress for free. And if you were one of the first purchasers, you get the next one free too.

 

Oh, the wise one comes to settle everything down.

Reply #64 Top

Quoting Fistalis, reply 60



"Elemental: Fallen Enchantress is expected to be released in the Summer of 2011. It will be free to those who purchased Elemental: War of Magic in 2010 and be available at a significant discount for those who purchase War of Magic."

It can be found here

https://forums.elementalgame.com/403846
  

Perfect, thanks! I missed that in the original.

Reply #65 Top

Quoting Frogboy, reply 62

You get Fallen Enchantress for free. And if you were one of the first purchasers, you get the next one free too.

Does this mean I have to stop calling the Maryland State Attorney General over and over now? 

I was having fun...

Reply #66 Top

Quoting Belwolvie, reply 47
Murteas et all,

I think what people are questioning is the fact that FE (Fallen Enchantress) is being introduced as a new game (possibly with the removal of some WoM play rules) not as an update with additional functionality/content on top of the base WoM (War of Magic), so therefore if you prefer the gameplay of 1.20 WoM you will not be able to play that with the additional content from FE.

Then when the 2nd expansion comes out will that be a modification of WoM again or FE?

I hope that makes sense

Now I'm not that concerned as I trust Brad, Derek and Jon's ability to make the right decisions.

 

 

^^ This is how I feel about it, what happens down the road if EWOM gets some cool new features in a patch that FE doesn't get, or FE get's some cool new features that EWOM doesn't get. How would I choose which to play if they both offer similar but different things, and I like BOTH for different features. Personally I would much rather have a expansion that builds upon the original game, rather than giving us something completely new, as that is what a expansion usually does. Then everything would be in one place.

The Total War series did the same thing, brought *expansions* that were really new games, but didn't build upon the original work, and because of that I never played them. I fear the same will happen with Elemental...

Reply #67 Top

Quoting Kantok, reply 65

Quoting Frogboy, reply 62
You get Fallen Enchantress for free. And if you were one of the first purchasers, you get the next one free too.
Does this mean I have to stop calling the Maryland State Attorney General over and over now? 

I was having fun...

I don't pay taxes to maryland so waste his time and maryland taxpayers money all you want...

Reply #68 Top

Quoting Fistalis, reply 67
I don't pay taxes to maryland so waste his time and maryland taxpayers money all you want...

Maybe they don't have anything else to do

Reply #69 Top

Both expansions will be free, for those of us who bought before oct 2010 and the original game will still be worked on continuing. Hope that clears things up!!!!!!!!!

Reply #70 Top

Simple people.

 

If you bought the game before Oct 2010 then you get both standalone future games for free.

 

If you bought the game after Oct 2010 but before the beginning of the year, then you get the first standalone free, and the second at a sharp discount.

 

Its unfortunate that so many forum users can't read a simple post given by the developer.  Its also sad that the education system of the US is making such stupid mindless people these days, oh wait, people actually voted for Sarah Palin.  I rest my case.

Reply #71 Top

Quoting Frogboy, reply 62

Quoting Freebird1956, reply 15I`m now confused ? I thought we were fixing the original game ? I understand the concept of a new game. Lets make the first group of purchasers happy. I`m one of those people. Make me happy that I bought your game in the firstplace. I will then consider making another purchase from Statdock. If I`m wrong in my thinking please let me know. Just for the record, I do feel that Stardock is heading in the right direction. Having great co-workers is going to be a plus. I see great things happenning at Stardock. I just want a complete follow thru before we start asking for another purchase. Thank you ...........

Freebird out of the birdcage for the moment.

You get Fallen Enchantress for free. And if you were one of the first purchasers, you get the next one free too.

 

Thank you for clarifying this. I'm all for making it standalone.

Reply #72 Top

Quoting Lothos, reply 49
I think you guys miss the point

If the classify it as a second game and never make an expansion for War of Magic that means the sales pitch they gave everyoen in December that if you guy the game before the end of the year you get the first expansion free has been null envoid and you get nothing for free.

What in essence they can do is now claim this new game as a new game and re-charge everyone for what really is the expansion for War of Magic and never have to keep their promise of having an expansion. They are not very clear on this and in essence this could be clasified as fraud. I specifically purchased Elemental for Christmas even though I knew the game was buggy and unplayable because of their offer and now with this unique wording they are resinding the offer (well it appears they may try since they are not clear). I have no problem contacting the Maryland State Attorney Generals office if this is the case. Done it with LucasArts so I don't see how this will be different but it just depends on what their intentions are. If they just want literall a stand alone expansion and use it still to honor their agreement with everyone who bought the game during the holidays then I am fine with that and will be happy.

Lol. Come on... You're trolling right? Did you even read the post and thread all the way through?

Reply #73 Top

So...when do I get my pony?  Brad?  Pony?  PONY!

Reply #74 Top

I still dont quite get why it has to be a new game...  I dont want to have to choose to play either EWoM or FE, I want to play EWoM with FE content, as an actual expansion.  I dont care if it's free or not, that isn't the point. 

Reply #75 Top

Quoting Wizaerd, reply 74
I still dont quite get why it has to be a new game...  I dont want to have to choose to play either EWoM or FE, I want to play EWoM with FE content, as an actual expansion.  I dont care if it's free or not, that isn't the point. 

 

Yep, I feel the same way. :'(