OffTopic - Fallout ... what's your opinion?

I love the series and the lore/story behind it all but if I had to pick my favourite game out of the three it would be Fallout 2 - just because I prefer the opening song

Prefer Fallout 1 in all its broken glory.  I think the most interesting part was that there were several classes of finish (complete victory, the master lives but mutant army destroyed, etc.) that you could only really discover if you were talking over with friends and you're like: yeah I killed the army base and it was awesome!  Your friend responds: but that's not the end of the game! ... best moment, period.

Also, I think there's a general gaming topic group you could move this into if you edited the first post.

yup... Fallout 2 is the best of them all

I used to know the exact words of the opening movie ...

war...war never changes.... the end of the world acured pretty much as we had predicted ... spears of nuckler fire and all that

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jNKUfk-MgJw&NR=1

ahh those were the days...

What a stupid topic...Fallout 1 and 2 are completely unplayable due to its completely obsolete graphics, animations and screen resolution.

Die.

You ARE Hortz!

Mmmkay. Could make your trolling attempts a little more subtle, y'know?

Unfortunatly I played Fallout 2 long before I had the chance to play Fallout 1. So I was much more hooked to F2 though playing F1 even years later was a blast.

I'm sure a lot of people might disagree but I can't say I didn't have a lot of fun playing F3. Yes yes, I thought a lot of the atmosphere and the humor that made the first two games amazing weren't quite there but still, the game is so huge both in size and scope of gameplay that I just can't say it wasn't fun. In short, even though I can't say F3 was one of my favorite games of all time, I still felt it was a great game.

I still play MoM, so Fallout 1 and 2 graphics should be fine for me too 

Btw shouldn't this thread go to the "PC gaming" section?

love 1 & 2

3 was good, but took the space of what could have been a better rpg

Haven't played Fallout. Fallout 2 was quite interesting altough I found myself wishing I could have played the original (because of setting). And Fallout 3 was like Oblivion: fun but not good (ambient was great and character creation was really well done though).

None of the Fallouts can compare to Wasteland, you posers.

god damn u are trying to win the troll of the year award

best rpg out there is still planescape torment, on story alone

OoooHHH Wasteland... I have the discs for that game... I didn't really get that game though.

yeah but F3 could have been so great... a legend even... its a shame

yeah if you are shallow enough to only care about graphics? its because of people like you that todays games dont have any depth .. i just cant.... ahh nevermind you will learn ... maybe

...wait ...sorry ... i am trying not to insult your intelligence ... but its so difficult .. anyway...

Wasteland makes no sense because I have no paragraph book.

You can always google for help with that problem.

Fallout 1 and 2 were both great games.  Fallout 3 = ok game that shouldn't have been called Fallout 3. Maybe Fallout: A New Beginning or something.  I don't hate the game but it was pretty repetitive after a while and was worse in many, many ways.  Really it was only better graphically.  Can't think of anything else about it that was superior.  Very sad, especially hearing how everyone (outside of this post anyway) raves about it.  Hoping Fallout: New Vegas will at least come a little closer to the old games.

I have to agree with edpfister. F3 was a better-looking game, not really a better game than F1 & 2.

I was stuck playing Baulders Gate over and over i only wish i had heard of fallout before the third one, or did i hear about it in the webcomic "ctrl alt del" before that mmm

Fallout 1 and 2 were great games. Character progression was one of the best (skills should have cost a different number per points as they weren't equally useful, but perks were brilliant). I think combat system of that style is more interesting in tactical JRPGs (like Disgaea, Final Fantasy Tactics or Gladius), but it isn't bad in Fallout either. Setting is 5+

I didn't even try Fallout 3. I was disappointed with Oblivion (i played Daggerfall and Morrowind, and i liked them more at the time of their release), so i didn't want to be disappointed with Fallout 3 either.

hmm i am making an online fallout game... the idea with the diff. cost of skill is a good one... i will implement it

thanks Ellestar

I really can say Fallout 1, is one of my All time favorite games. Fallout 2, was a fantastic continuation of the series. Both were just great games, (though not with their .. ahem bugs).

As far as Fallout 3, I've not completed it due to graphics glitch, and a bit of boredom. But that being said, I think it's a wonderful game for what it is, an artists recreation of a beloved series in a different perspective. 

Different, with it's own very strong gotcha moments. (How about not realizing that in the PC you can press your tab key to get light), and playing the game without a light, at all for your character.. moving through the darkness being hunted by rabid ghouls. That's some great stuff. And the game did a fantastic job of making you realize, the end of the world would suck. There is nothing really redeemable about the habitants of that post eastern society. Much less nostalgic as it were.

Also, I felt 3 went a bit overboard with upping the cheese of the alternate 50's future. Just felt a bit too dominating.

Now, that said.. 1 & 2 really shone strong. 3 Shone with a new light, strong, but not really making you feel like you reconnected with an old friend. But a new friend, different, and not all together strange, but not bad either. Just an artists recreation. One of many proposed ones over the years. So, good deal for what it was.

Sorry for rambling on in here on this, off topic subject. But I can honestly say I hope, and have no doubts that Elemental: War of Magic will be something I look back on 5 years later and find myself still playing, and enjoying all the new expansions, and preparations for the sequel.

I don't think Fallout 3 was a particularly faithful recreation. Fallout 1 and 2 were desolate and depressing. where there were no real "good guys", just people looking out for themselves. Being a hero (if you chose that path) made you an exception, there was pretty much only. Whereas, I feel Fallout 3 didn't do a good job of being as dark and hopeless as the other Fallouts were. Firstly, the environment was very "busy", which I thought was a good thing but not really true to Fallout. There was a much stronger line between "good" and "evil" in Fallout 3. A lot of themes simply didn't transfer from the original Fallouts.

I guess I really want a post-apocalyptic survival simulation, sort of like UnReal World. Most post apocalyptic fiction and games have become very science-fictiony in a way I think sort of defeats the purpose of post-apocalyptic fiction. An post-apocalyptic open-world sandbox RPG would be, in a word, amazing.