Stargate Atlantis

I dont know if this is the right place to post this, but I have a few questions.

First, i'd like to say that I was not a fan of Stargate SG-1, but lately a friend convince me to watch o few episodes, so I did. It wasn't so bad, so I bought the first 3 seasons, and after that all the season up to the 7th. Now that I have finish watching the first 7 seasons, I ordered the last 3, I should have them by the end of the week.

1. Should I buy Stargate Atlantis?, is it any good?, is it better or worse then SG-1, it only lasted 5 seasons, so I'm gessing it didn't go too well?

2. If I do buy Altantis, when should I start watching it, are Atlantis and SG-1 related (storywise), I saw somehere that SG-1 ended in 2007, but Atlanstis started in 2005? if so, should I wait before watching SG-1 season 8?

I know, so many questions, but I could really use some help trying to figure out what to watch and when!

Help please!

75,459 views 10 replies
Reply #2 Top

Wow...  You bought a lot of Stargate.

 

I'd put Atlantis after the first five seasons of SG-1, those are just plain badass, but before the decline.  It's way better than the post-gould ori arc.  About the time the cast started ditching SG-1, it was past time to kill the slow.  I'm rather glad they ended Atlantis before they went too long with it.

 

You've already reached where they launch the Atlantis expedition in SG1, they'll reference each other occasionally.  If you really want to you can watch them in order, but it's not necessary.  They maintain continuity, but don't leave you wondering wtf is going on as long as you have the gist of the two shows.

Reply #4 Top

Quoting Moosetek13, reply 1
Simply start at the beginning.

???

Quoting psychoak, reply 2
Wow...  You bought a lot of Stargate.

 

I'd put Atlantis after the first five seasons of SG-1, those are just plain badass, but before the decline.  It's way better than the post-gould ori arc.  About the time the cast started ditching SG-1, it was past time to kill the slow.  I'm rather glad they ended Atlantis before they went too long with it.

 

You've already reached where they launch the Atlantis expedition in SG1, they'll reference each other occasionally.  If you really want to you can watch them in order, but it's not necessary.  They maintain continuity, but don't leave you wondering wtf is going on as long as you have the gist of the two shows.

Yes I did!

Whats a gould ori??? (nerver mind, I guess i'll find out by the end of next week)

Cast ditching SG-1??? you're probably talking about DR. Fraisier and Richard Dean Anderson (in season 9-10).

If I read your post right, Atlantis is "badass", better than SG-1?

So I should buy Atlantis and watch season 1 at the same time has I am watching SG-1 season 8?

Quoting CommanderAdama, reply 3
http://www.hulu.com/videos/search?query=stargate+atlantis

http://www.mininova.org/

 

Dont be a sukka.

I dont watch TV shows on the internet, I prefer my 65" TV, but tx anyway.

Reply #5 Top

having just watched them all (since jan) but the last season and a half of atlantis, defintily get atlantis.the first season'sa bit meh but picks up and has some major sh*t happen, at points better than SG-1 imho. it's worth it for Mckay alone.

i tried to watch them in order as i didn't no how they would reference to each other. in the end i could happily have watched them seperately (and maybe enjoyed the 1st season of atlantis more, with out getting siddetrackedby SG-1)

MrL

+1 Loading…
Reply #6 Top

I would rate SG-1 better than Atlantis, overall. It had a bit of a rough start in the first 2 seasons or so, but after that it picked up nicely. SG-1 has the benefit of being set against the backdrop of common mythology (Egyptian and Norse primarily, and some King Arthur fables towards the end) so it's interesting how they make you think and realize how in the SG-world the ancient and powerful civilizations shaped Earth's culture and mythology.

Atlantis doesn't get the benefit of that, it's purely a spin-off show. There are some loose tie-ins and some crossing story arcs here and there, but from a story perspective it's nothing terribly amazing. The visuals are neat enough and there are some rather epic episodes, but ultimately I think it was a show without much central direction or "goal". The writers wasted some great opportunities for plot arcs along the way, and dwelled on others long enough to make it very groan-worthy ("Oh god, not this bad guy again.." sort of thing).

From the action perspective, you would probably like Atlantis better (though once the Ori came into play, SG-1 had its share of flashyness). From a story perspective, SG-1 can beat Atlantis hands down. Atlantis just can't match the epic-ness of the stories of SG-1, like Anubis kidnapping Thor to gain the Asgard knowledge, and the buildup/showdown between the Ascended Daniel and half-ascended Anubis. :P

The Ori arc in SG-1 is a bit clunkier since it's tied to King Arthur fables which aren't as natural of a fit as Egyptian and Norse mythos, so I would say SG-1 is at its best in the middle.

+1 Loading…
Reply #7 Top

I liked Atlantis much more than SG1. However both series are great. Now I wait for the fifth season to be available, so I can buy it together.

Reply #8 Top

Should I buy Stargate Atlantis?, is it any good?, is it better or worse then SG-1, it only lasted 5 seasons, so I'm gessing it didn't go too well?

 

It have go well and more long that planned... normally, in fall2007, SCI FI channel have planned the start for Stargate Universe... But the the writer's strike put a hold on the project. Now, Stargate Universe is currently in development. First episode in 2009...

 

The idea of Stargate Universe is that it is set on a ship that was part of an Ancient experiment that was set in motion probably millions of years ago, one that they never saw to fruition, but that we can. The experiment is to send a ship across the universe, and to send one ahead of it to seed the galaxies with Stargates, and that they would one day use the stargate's ninth chevron to gate to the ship. Millions of years ago (before their conflict with the Wraith and even before they moved Atlantis to the Pegasus Galaxy), the show would reveal, the Ancients sent out two ships: an automated vessel to place Stargates throughout multiple galaxies in our universe, and a second ship to follow up and explore. A standard, 7-symbol gate address allows for travel within the same galaxy. Use of the Stargate's eighth chevron allows for travel to a different galaxy. And the ninth chevron will allow the team to reach this second Ancient ship, the Destiny.

Reply #9 Top

It sounds interesting enough, but I'm curious how they'll manage to find enough ZPMs to power the gate to do that. Atlantis and Earth aren't exactly crawling with them :P

Reply #10 Top

When Atlantis came back to Earth, it was using the full complement of 3 ZPMs. How much power is left in them is anyones guess. Given that the premise for SGU has the check it out team stuck on the Destiny, I think we can make some guesses.