Howdidudothat Howdidudothat

I want to demonstrate carrier counters to you [Updated 2/27]

I want to demonstrate carrier counters to you [Updated 2/27]

EDIT:  Now that flak has been buffed and carriers have been nerfed, does anyone still want to participate in this demonstration?

 

Ok, so apparently people just don't get it (see the replies to this thread https://forums.sinsofasolarempire.com/340339 and the various threads about needing to nerf carriers). 

So to all of you who think carriers are OP, I am CALLING YOU OUT.  That's right.  Tonight, from 7 pm to 10 pm EST, I will play you in a team game.  I promise to build no more than 1 for every 5 cruiser carriers you have.  I will show you how to counter carriers properly.  At the end of the demonstration, we will then determine if a nerf is really needed.  I invite the developers as well.  My screen name on ICO is "[DT]Howthe?"  Be there or be square.  If you want to reply to this thread and reserve a spot either on my team or the opposing team, just sign up.  I'll then go ahead and make a roster.

EDIT:  When you sign up, make sure to post your screenname, with proper spelling.

Roster for 7 pm game 2/27/09:  ICO updated during the time we had.

Carrier Killing Team   vs   Carrier Spamming Team

[DT]Howthe?  __________________  Agent of Karma

[_]-Flipkik   ____________________  [SP]TheTraviler

ravok2789  ____________________

KEN  ______________________

 

EDIT:  Here is a replay (for what it's worth) of a game I just played against a carrier spammer.  As you can see, carriers are not a game winner.  http://www.fileden.com/files/2008/8/7/2039910/AutoRecord-02211859.record

263,361 views 126 replies
Reply #126 Top

Quoting CreditSuisse, reply 7
Your logic is pretty [censored] up. 

Go read these lists of logical fallacies. I bet if you took the LSATs now you would epic fail. 

List of fallacies - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

You just used an ad hominem. 

 

He didn't. He didn't insult the playing skills of other people at all. He said there are strategies which can be used (but aren't) by players to beat the carrier spam. 

 

Finally. Philosophy Logic is largely useless in a real argument because you can always question any assumption. Why should he go read the logical fallacies? Why are they called logical fallacies? What is logic? What is a fallacy? etc. 

 

Now Philosophy aside, stop being an ass.