I was reflecting on this some more through the day today, and something else hit me.
I've always been a very sentimental soul when it comes to 'God & Country' stuff, don't ask me why. I still get a little choked up during the National Anthem any time I hear it. Give me a military jet team flying overhead & I'm completely verklempt.
As moving as Obama's speech was, it never stirred any sort of emotional reaction in me. Not the case with Palin's - parts of it did choke me up a bit, simple & straightforward as it was.
Perhaps I'm wrong, but I think the differing responses related to my inate 'sincerity meter' - I found Palin to be more genuine & Obama to be too polished, too 'engineered,' too Hollywood slick.
Those feelings were reinforced a bit this evening, if indirectly. I did not get to see the Saddleback Forum at the time it aired, but I watched all of it this evening. The contrast between the men was stark. Obama tiptoeing on eggshells for an hour, hyperexplaining, hyperqualifying, constantly looking for a way to say two things at once, somewhat defensive or afraid to offend. McCain polite but blunt, concise & without hesitation or fear. The difference could be seen in their eyes and body language - you didn't even need audio. McCain is comfortable in his own skin & grounded in his beliefs, whether you agree with them or not. Obama didn't seem sure of much of anything.
0.02