Philocthetes Philocthetes

Bloatware go bye-bye?

Bloatware go bye-bye?

I post from GC2-land, and I've been seeing quite a bit of talk lately about keeping a clean PC (a goal I admire, but no longer persue with the rigor that I should). I thought some of y'all might be interested to see that the subject is actually getting some NYTimes coverage.

It's an interesting story about the way Best Buy (Geek Squad) is trying to balance keeping major vendors happy with earning extra bucks by cleaning up after said vendors. Until today, I didn't know that you could actually do what I think I saw Mumblefratz say he'd like to do, which is pay $30 extra to get the new box without crapware.

107,515 views 41 replies
Reply #26 Top

I find that the edit button usually appears if you switch over to another SD site real quick

I find things working "properly" to be much better than workarounds. Also, I use no other SD sites, so I have no shortcuts to them and am not interested in testing to find out just how quick "real quick" is.

Reply #27 Top
Also, I use no other SD sites, so I have no shortcuts to them
Here's a partial list to get you started. It shouldn't take you *too* long to find one that works for you.

 

www.wincustomize.com
www.impulsedriven.net
www.sinsofasolarempire.com

But seriously, this should at the least give you some idea of the potential difficulties faced by the Web team which, from what I've heard, is at this point is down to only Andrew as all the other web developers have their hands full with Impulse.

As I said this is probably only a partial list but each site has a certain amount of overlap with pretty much every other site and it appears to me that most sites evolved independently with subtle and not so subtle differences in functionality. I'm not surprised that changes introduced in one part of the system have unanticipated consequences in other parts.

I for one would prefer the sites be more compartmentalized but that's another conversation that has already been discussed and dismissed.

One thing that's humorous to note is that in some parts of the system a double space carriage return is the norm whereas in others, single space works just fine. Copying part of this thread from a different area of the system resulted in double space carriage returns at the beginning of my reply but single space returns after pasting in my list. Go figure.

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.

[edit] I obviously spoke too soon. The mix of double and single space carriage returns which looked fine while I was writing the post resulted in a reply that had no returns at all. Then of course I was caught by the can't edit problem so I jumped over to wincustomize but my reply wasn't there yet, so I waited a bit and then when my reply appeared I couldn't edit it there either so I jumped over to impulsedriven and I was able to edit there. This obviously makes GW's point for him. [/edit]

Actually I had to jump back here (galciv2) to edit the carraige returns because they appear to work *nowhere* else.

Reply #28 Top

Generally I just pop over to GalCiv2. (By replacing whatever is in forums.~~~.com) That brings me directly to where I need to be, and switching to the GalCiv2 site has worked every time for me. As for how long it takes, I suppose that depends on your computer and connection. Generally only a few seconds for me.

But yes, I'd prefer it working properly as well.

 

:fox:

Reply #29 Top

OEM EULA only states you can't put it on another pc. No stopping you from reinstalling OEM.
The OEM disk is not an install disk but a restore disk. You can certainly use it to restore the original OEM image but that of course leaves you with all the crap that you wanted to eliminate in the first place.

I always do a clean install regardless if it's a PC I built, or one like my HP laptop. I see no reason to pay for something as easy as doing it yourself.
That's definitely a better option but that assumes you have a separate install media for the OS which most folks would have to purchase separately.

For those who want to get rid of bloatware on Propriety machines (dunno why anybody 'd wanna buy one), head over to Majorgeeks WWW Link and get Decrapifier.
I did actually use this but there were a number of items on the machine that weren't on the listed apps. The other point in my case was that HP embeds a bios/driver auto update mechanism that is threaded throughout the system. The only way to get rid of that was surgical extraction from the registry and deletion of a multitude of startup items.

As far as why anyone would want to buy one it's most likely that they just don't know any better or are afraid of going to someone like ibuypower or newegg to build their own. In my case I was just being lazy as the last time I had purchased an OEM machine was before 95 was even out and all you needed to do was take your hard drive from the old machine and put it in the new one and you had everything just as you had on the old machine. You might have to change a video or other driver but things were far simpler. Anyway next machine I buy will definitely *not* be from an major OEM.

Reply #30 Top

One thing that's humorous to note is that in some parts of the system a double space carriage return is the norm whereas in others, single space works just fine. Copying part of this thread from a different area of the system resulted in double space carriage returns at the beginning of my reply but single space returns after pasting in my list. Go figure.

In the new update (the latest version of the postbox, in particular), the default behavior of the enter key seems now to insert a paragraph tag, rather than a line break. You can still do a line break via shift-enter, though.

Reply #31 Top

In the new update (the latest version of the postbox, in particular), the default behavior of the enter key seems now to insert a paragraph tag, rather than a line break. You can still do a line break via shift-enter, though.
Shift-enter. Thanks.

Testing paragraph tag

Testing shift-enter
Testing paragraph tag

Testing shift-enter
Testing shift-enter
Testing paragraph tag

Testing 2 shift-enter's

[edit] Nice. Seems to work fine. Thanks again. [/edit]

Reply #32 Top

In the new update (the latest version of the postbox, in particular), the default behavior of the enter key seems now to insert a paragraph tag, rather than a line break. You can still do a line break via shift-enter, though.

 

And i already thought it was because i updated to firefox 3.

Reply #33 Top

And i already thought it was because i updated to firefox 3.

I thought it was FF also, b/c the site is broken in Opera now and I'm having to use my second-choice browser.

But, really, I'm still hoping to hear whether anyone thinks that the Times story I linked might indicate a real market shift in the bloatware problem or if it is just a momentary thing. I know there are some serious followers of the IT biz around here...

Reply #34 Top

But, really, I'm still hoping to hear whether anyone thinks that the Times story I linked might indicate a real market shift in the bloatware problem or if it is just a momentary thing.
At the moment, I'm thinking it's a momentary thing, but that may (hopefully) change.

 

:fox:

Reply #35 Top

I think if they do get rid of the current form of bloatware something will replace it. If profit margins are as slim as suggested in the story, then PC manufacturers will be forced to think of another way to stay in the green. Whatever it is they come up with will most likely not be in the best interest of the consumer.

Last OEM machine I bought was a 400Mhz Celeron, in the days when a PII 450Mhz was top of the line. It was a mistake I have avoided repeating since :)

Reply #36 Top
Whatever it is they come up with will most likely not be in the best interest of the consumer


That's why I'd never, ever buy an OEM rig again... you get what they decide is best for you, and most often it isn't. And is often the case with lower end OEM's, they have little or no room for expansion or upgrade, meaning that if you want/need to do more than it can, you need to buy another, more expensive machine with more bloat to gunk it up.

Nope, that's not for me. I'll stick with building my own, with a bit of help/advice from my trusted local PC guy. That way I know exactly what I'm getting, that its upgradable if/when needed and has no damned bloatware/trial versions, etc.
Reply #37 Top
I agree I do both.. I by "premade" systems ... my new one being a dell Studio laptop and I also have my hubby make pcs from scratch.

I do NOT like pre loaded OS's. So after I got my dell studio lappy I took my own windows OS disc and reformatted the hard drive.

I choose MYSELF what OS and what PROGRAMS I want on any of my systems.
=
I learned ways back when I first started messing with comps on how to format and partition drives and how to install OS's. Hubby knows quite a bit and taught me well.

It gives me a piece of mind knowing what exactly is on my systems :)..

I wouldn't pay anyone to reformat or partition my drives or install an OS *sadly I learned Windows*..

Though I am glad that there are companies like Best Buy and Comp Usa that do have that service.


My thoughts.

Anne :D
Reply #38 Top
What a totally cool name. Decrapifier...I love it.
Reply #39 Top

I'm with the people who build their own systems - OEM stuff just isn't worth it anymore. My current system is self built, and I've even built the system that belongs to my parents. No extra junk, just what they want.

Reply #40 Top

Please, I consider the OEM vs custom box question settled and I haven't noticed anyone here trying to praise OEM boxes. I just found the idea that a major OEM would put itself in conflict with bloatware vendors by offering "cleaner" machines interesting, and hopefully the beginning of a trend.

Even if most folks around here are not going to suffer directly from bloatware, many of us are the kinds of folks who get asked to help out with PC problems in our home lives. The death of bloatware would make those little favors much easier in many cases.

Reply #41 Top

When I brought my XP I got ton of bloatware games. 5 year later When I got the vista I got the same bloatware. EVEN The same games and this is 5 years later. Tell me I don't want to play demo I see it and I uninstall it.

 

These scams is target to the people who don't know computers or how it function it.