Gene Nash

Join Date 12/2003

+24

Kerry's Ads Prove He's Out of Touch

could he take a picture with Saddam and Osama?

Even if a leader marches to the beat of his own drum, he should still have his finger on the pulse of the people. After all, if one is to lead, you must know where the people are before you can take them to where you want them. Then why are John Kerry's current trumpet blowing ads so out of touch with what Americans value and believe?

In a current ad, Kerry lays out what he thinks will convince people he is qualified for the presidency. (In another version, a narrator speaks, though most the same points are covered.)

Kerry speaks of being born in a military hospital and how his father proudly served and his mother was a "community activist," though what that activism entailed isn't stated. Question: Do you see "community activists" (a.k.a. "do gooders") as a positive thing? Unless you happen to be one, or close to one, many people speak of "do gooders" derisively. Do you really want to identify yourself as coming from a long line of them, Mr. Kerry? Besides, having accomplished ancestors does not mean you are anything special.

Kerry goes on to speak of why he joined the military, saying, "...if you had a lot of privileges as I had had-- to go to a great university like Yale...." Stop tape. Do you really want to remind the average, struggling American just how special and privileged you are, Mr. Kerry? You know how they just love the rich folk, right? An Ivy League man yet? It's a wonder you haven't been crowned King already!

Bring on Mr. Kerry's war photos, please. Add a couple of vets to tell us what a hero John was. Yes, at this point it's good to remind people of Mr. Kerry's roll in America's most popular war. People will eat that up.

Okay, he's praising himself too much. Bring on his daughter to point out some of her dad's other accomplishments, like being a prosecutor. That'll be great! People love lawyers! Have her remind people he's a senator, too. People love politicians even more than they love lawyers.

Bring down Mrs. Kerry-- sorry, Ms. Heinz Kerry. Finally another activist First Lady in the mold of Hillary Rodham Clinton. Good. Good. The ubber-rich wife with the foreign accent. Americans love that. It's so Dynasty. Remind us again how privileged you are. You married into massive wealth, Mr. Kerry! How surprising your WASP guilt didn't cause you to enlist in another war to compensate for that. Oh, did they close the French Foreign Legion?

Yes Mr. Kerry has done an excellent job of identifying all the things people love and placing himself smack in the center of them. Way to go, John!

[Click here to see a version of this ad.]

politics

Locked Post

Advanced Search

Watch this post

Do not email me updates for this post Email me updates for this post

Successfully updated karma reason!

KarmaGirl

Join Date 03/2001

+118

I should have not clicked on that link.

I'm way too much of a cynic. When the guy said "he risked his life by pulling me out of the river" I was just thinking of what the whole story was: "Well, we were drinking and a bit high at the time. Bob thought it would be funny to push me into the river. John was so drunk he could barely see, but he risked his life by pulling me out of the river because neither of us were smart enough to realize that it was only 4 feet deep and we could have just stood up."

I wonder how much they paid those guys to endorse him......

Not that I think that President Bush is any better- he just seems wise enough to not put out ads like that.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Smartaz, the idea of Kerry's ads is to appeal to undecideds and independents, something you are clearly not. People do love lawyers, when they're prosecutors. DAs rarely lose races, unless they have a tendency to lose.

Give us all a break.

Cheers

Successfully updated karma reason!

The *real* story is actually quite heroic. From Snopes (politically neutral site):
http://www.snopes.com/politics/kerry/service.asp

Kerry was injured yet again on 13 March 1969, in an action for which he was awarded both a Bronze Star and his third Purple Heart. According to Kerry's Bronze Star citation (signed by Admiral Zumwalt himself):

Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry was serving as an Officer-in-Charge of Inshore Patrol Craft 94, one of five boats conducting a Sealords operation in the Bay Hap River. While exiting the river, a mine detonated under another Inshore Patrol Craft and almost simultaneously, another mine detonated wounding Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry in the right arm. In addition, all units began receiving small arms and automatic weapons fire from the river banks. When Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry discovered he had a man overboard, he returned upriver to assist. The man in the water was receiving sniper fire from both banks. Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry directed his gunners to provide suppressing fire, while from an exposed position on the bow, his arm bleeding and in pain and with disregard for his personal safety, he pulled the man aboard. Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry then directed his boat to return to and assist the other damaged boat to safety. Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry's calmness, professionalism and great personal courage under fire were in keeping with the highest traditions of the United States Naval Service.

Successfully updated karma reason!

And being highly privileged somehow appeals to undecided and independents?

Successfully updated karma reason!

People like him apparently. Go figure. Must be his message is working, and YOU'RE "Out of Touch"

Successfully updated karma reason!

Two lies in that ad: 1) Kerry did not join the Navy because he felt he had to give something back to the country where he could go to Yale, he joined so that he would not be drafted. He first went to his draft board and asked for an exemption to study in France. When he was turned down, he enlisted in the Navy rather than be drafted and assigned to the Marines or Army. (Not that I wouldn't do the same).
2) Kerry claims that he and McCain did so much for the POW issue in Viet Nam. To the contrary, Kerry is said to have blocked any real inquiry into MIAs and refused to allow any witnesses who might have provided information on living US troops being held in Viet Nam after the war.

Successfully updated karma reason!

People like him apparently. Go figure. Must be his message is working, and YOU'RE "Out of Touch"

It might also be that they'd vote for anybody who isn't Bush, no matter how bad they are.

Successfully updated karma reason!

"Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry was serving as an Officer-in-Charge of Inshore Patrol Craft 94, one of five boats conducting a Sealords operation in the Bay Hap River. While exiting the river, a mine detonated under another Inshore Patrol Craft and almost simultaneously, another mine detonated wounding Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry in the right arm. In addition, all units began receiving small arms and automatic weapons fire from the river banks. When Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry discovered he had a man overboard, he returned upriver to assist. The man in the water was receiving sniper fire from both banks. Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry directed his gunners to provide suppressing fire, while from an exposed position on the bow, his arm bleeding and in pain and with disregard for his personal safety, he pulled the man aboard. Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry then directed his boat to return to and assist the other damaged boat to safety. Lieutenant (junior grade) Kerry's calmness, professionalism and great personal courage under fire were in keeping with the highest traditions of the United States Naval Service."

Can you imagine Bush doing ANY of that? (I don't know how to do the yellow background quotes that people are doing)

Successfully updated karma reason!

kingbee

Join Date 04/2004

+42

Can you imagine Bush doing ANY of that?

maybe not but hows this? i can envision ol george wearing a seal team wetsuit (complete with fins) roaring up to a dock at the controls of a cigarette racer before disembarking to make a triumphant speech under a big banner emblazoned with the words "SUCCESS AT SEA"

Successfully updated karma reason!

the reason he brings up yale and vietnam is probably not to show he is a smarty pants, but that he went to yale and then went to vietnam and hopes voters will think of some other guy running for president who also graduated yale at about the same time as vietnam.

jon stewart made fun of kerry on the daily show with that part of the ad, saying that such a subtle jab would go over the heads of most voters. and that's why a comedy satire politcal show has the most insightful news reporting

ps: non-satire pic of rumsfeld and sadaam together

hi, how ya doing, good to meet ya...

Successfully updated karma reason!

I think it's actually quite smart what Kerry is doing. By emphasising his "breeding" and his military background he is always going to look good (for the undecided voter) when compared to GWB. It's a two-horse race, no need to be everyones favorite son-in-law, just be a little less of a sob than the other guy.

Successfully updated karma reason!

I have a feeling that the Democrats' half-ass plan to win the presidency with a candidate that is similar and only minutely better in the eyes of some individuals is going to backfire.
By the way, is Kerry taking a stand on any issue yet or is he still straddling the fence?

Successfully updated karma reason!

Actually...being in the minority of these comments I'd like to agree with you. I think he's trying WAY too hard...it's kind of sad how he keeps pushing all of his ancestors and compliments...eventually I belive the people will be a tad bit annoyed about him bragging all the time....Me personally...I'm ticked at Bush and Kerry for these stupid commercials...AHHH....they're so trite...I'm tired of it and I'm only a teenager.....I have to go through this every 4 years for several years to come...I'm not even politcally biased. I wish they'd just hold the stupid elections early so I don't have to keep hearing this...oh well, what can ya do?

~Zoo

Successfully updated karma reason!

I was under the impression that everybody loves a hero. Support and gratitude for our troops also goes for honorable veterans. It's pretty sad to doubt official documents heralding one's heroic acts.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Is a veteran honorable who acts insincerely in the hopes of gaining power?

Successfully updated karma reason!

kingbee

Join Date 04/2004

+42

Is a veteran honorable who acts insincerely in the hopes of gaining power?

youre thinking kerry pulled strings to get stationed in prime potentially heroic deed locations and arranged for the river to be mined all as part of a plan to eventually run for president?

one so rarely sees that sort of determination and ambition anymore (a less motivated potential candidate would probably had his dad do the string pulling).

Successfully updated karma reason!

Draginol

Join Date 03/2001

+137

It's pretty sad to doubt official documents heralding one's heroic acts.

. Of course, it's okay to accuse Bush of going AWOL even though his official documents show he was honorably discharged.

Successfully updated karma reason!

kingbee

Join Date 04/2004

+42

it's okay to accuse Bush of going AWOL

in any other context but election year party politics--say at a neighborhood barbeque or in an office environment--i cant imagine anyone being anything but impressed by a service record like kerry's. i've only known one person (of no fewer than 100 vietnam vets with whom ive socialized enough to discuss their military experiences) who could match it.. i've also known about 25 vietnam-era vets--guys who were in the service but never left the states or who were stationed in europe. in the situations i described in the first sentence, i have an even more difficult time imagining someone with a record like bush's opening himself to ridicule by suggesting there was any basis for comparison.

Successfully updated karma reason!

youre thinking kerry pulled strings to get stationed in prime potentially heroic deed locations and arranged for the river to be mined all as part of a plan to eventually run for president?

one so rarely sees that sort of determination and ambition anymore (a less motivated potential candidate would probably had his dad do the string pulling).

No, I'm talking about after the Vietnam War (i.e. during his protesting years in which he was so insincere that he used fake medals when everybody else used real ones). He might be a hero, but he still has skeletons in his closet, and those skeletons are significant.

Successfully updated karma reason!

kingbee

Join Date 04/2004

+42

he used fake medals when everybody else used real ones). He might be a hero, but he still has skeletons in his closet, and those skeletons are significant.

now im even more confused. he was awarded real medals in recognition of his actions in combat. im guessing youre referring to kerry participating in a symbolic protest against the vietnam conflict during which he discarded the ribbons from his real medals. if so, your original conclusion ( acts insincerely in the hopes of gaining power ) is predicated on the belief he did that as part of a long-range plan to be elected president? i have no idea what's in his closet (except i guess no medal ribbons) but their absence is hardly a skeleton much less one of any significance.

if he hadnt been acted heroically, he would not have been awarded medals.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Speaking of heroic actions, did anyone mention our president, George W. Bush. We all have the priviledge to sit around and second guess his every move, and that's great; but he is the man leading the country in this struggle we find ourselves in. He, thank God, takes his vow to defend the people of this great nation seriously. He takes council with the leaders of the various agencies and departments formed for our defence, and it falls on him to call the shots. Does anyone think it a small thing to send men and women into battle? The war being waged in Iraq is a just war. We did not have the time to figure out every angle of such an endeavour, but something had to be done. Something courageous and bold was and is the order for the day. President Bush was right in ignoring the hesitancies of less motivated leaders. We were mercilessly attacked by wicked and hateful men who are looking for worse ways to hurt us. That's motivation. We would be the country that would be carrying the most part of the burden no matter when the time came, and acting when and how he did was in the belief that American lives would be saved. Motivation, no? The man is a current, tried and tested genuine hero in my book. He is our president, and we need to get behind him as the commander and chief of our armed forces. Pray that God bless him with the wisdom needed for these perilous times. Neither John Kerry nor any of his party's leadership can take W's place. Democrats and Independants, now is the time to come on board with the Grand Old Party, the Republicans, and give a loud and clear message to our enemies that we are one people you do not want to mess with. Pray for peace.

Successfully updated karma reason!

"Speaking of heroic actions, did anyone mention our president, George W. Bush. "

no, except in a negative light.

"He takes council with the leaders of the various agencies and departments formed for our defence, and it falls on him to call the shots. "

he ignored a lot of agencies and departments about iraq's capabilities and warnings that iraq would not be an easy place to occupy. he placed a bit too much confidence in the iraqi dissadents. given the number of screwups after the war was won, there just didn't seem to be that much planning for the occupation. he had to make decisions but i get the feeling he should have cast a wider net for differing opinions.

"Does anyone think it a small thing to send men and women into battle? "

nope.

"The war being waged in Iraq is a just war. "

while sadaam was a pos, he was pretty much "bottled up" as cheney said. i thought it was a just war going in but there weren't massive piles of wmds like i expected. no nukes. liberating the iraqi people was a secondary benefit, not the main reason we went to war.

cheney says sadaam "bottled up": http://www.whitehouse.gov/vicepresident/news-speeches/speeches/vp20010916.html

"We did not have the time to figure out every angle of such an endeavour, but something had to be done. Something courageous and bold was and is the order for the day. President Bush was right in ignoring the hesitancies of less motivated leaders. "

we kicked out sadaam but were wrong on wmd (other than 2 sarin shells that were found, we were expecting dumps and truckloads). now we have to make sure iraq doesn't collapse into a haven for terrorists (or an even bigger one). i would preferred he had not been so hasty. at the least he could have spent more time on possible outcomes other than 'iraqis will toss flowers at us.'

"We were mercilessly attacked by wicked and hateful men who are looking for worse ways to hurt us. That's motivation. "

please tell me if there are any iraqi links to the terrorist attacks on the us prior to the war. i am pretty sure there aren't. spec ops guys hunting for osama were pulled off so they could look for sadaam.
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2004-03-28-troop-shifts_x.htm

"We would be the country that would be carrying the most part of the burden no matter when the time came, and acting when and how he did was in the belief that American lives would be saved. "

he really really wanted to attack iraq and seemed to want an excuse. there are lots of news stories about how after 9/11 he and wolfowitz wanted to to hit iraq..

"He is our president, and we need to get behind him as the commander and chief of our armed forces. Pray that God bless him with the wisdom needed for these perilous times."

he's our president and we need to support him when he makes the right decisions to make sure our troops and armed forces are used wisely.

"Neither John Kerry nor any of his party's leadership can take W's place. Democrats and Independants, now is the time to come on board with the Grand Old Party, the Republicans, and give a loud and clear message to our enemies that we are one people you do not want to mess with. Pray for peace. "

i do pray for peace on earth every night. and my main action in november to make it so is to vote democrat.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Bush surely is AWOL when it comes to Afghanistan.

Successfully updated karma reason!

"Question: Do you see "community activists" (a.k.a. "do gooders") as a positive thing?"

Google "community activist". Read the links. Find me one, just one, that uses "community activist" as a derogatory term, as you seem to think it is.

"Besides, having accomplished ancestors does not mean you are anything special."

Does he claim it does? (I can't get the video to work due to internet settings, so I'll have to rely on someone telling me whether he does or not). But if he didn't mention his family, I can just see someone commenting that that must mean he's ashamed of them. Furthermore, it's not like mentioning one's upbringing in a political advertisment is atypical.

"Do you really want to remind the average, struggling American just how special and privileged you are, Mr. Kerry?"

Ah, but Mr. Kerry's point seems to be that despite his being born (and he hardly had a choice in the matter, so why you find fault with this I can't imagine) in a wealthy family, he doesn't feel "special and priveledged". He could have taken the easy way out, such as using his family's influence to join the National Guard (and notice I'm not against people joining the National Guard, but rather the use of one's family's influence to do so), but chose not to.

"Yes, at this point it's good to remind people of Mr. Kerry's roll [sic] in America's most popular war."

A war he happened to protest against, so it doesn't seem too popular with Mr. Kerry either.

" People love lawyers! Have her remind people he's a senator, too. People love politicians even more than they love lawyers."

jeblackstar already covered the prosecuter angle. But if smartaz is correct about how people view politicians, then Bush better not mention that's he's the president (*gasp* a POLITICIAN!) in any of his ads or he too must be out of touch with the American people- at least according to smartaz.

"Bring down Mrs. Kerry...."

What? Is he supposed to be ashamed of her? (Here, honey- hide in the closet until after the election if you would please)

"Finally another activist First Lady in the mold of Hillary Rodham Clinton."

Who is so hated by New Yorkers that they elected her senator (ooh, what vile punishment- they must have done that so they could hate her even more, seeing as how reviled politicians are).

"The ubber [sic]-rich wife with the foreign accent."

Maybe he feels that she has qualities that more than make up for this, such as her being highly-educated and caring.

"You married into massive wealth, Mr. Kerry!"

If you have some special means beyond the abilities of us poor mortals to determine the reasons why he married Ms Heinz Kerry, then it might just be possible that he did so out of his love for her.

"How surprising your WASP guilt didn't cause you to enlist in another war to compensate for that."

Are you basing your diagnosis of Mr. Kerry's "WASP guilt" on some sort of professional psychological analysis or is this just your opinion? And even if he does have "WASP guilt" wouldn't this be cause to oppose war, rather than support it?

Basically, the argument seems to be that Mr. Kerry is out of touch with America for having a campaign ad that has elements that could be found in similiar ads from perhaps 99% of the people running for office. Over all, a nice ad hominem piece there, smartaz- might we stick with the issues next time?

Successfully updated karma reason!

Many presidents have sprung from the privileged class, including the current one. Washington and Jefferson were not paupers, you know.

Successfully updated karma reason!